My Profile

  • User Name: Toshiro
  • Member Since: Thursday, December 18, 2003, 6:12 PM
  • Donation Level: Total Leech (Participant)
  • Location: Japan and USA
  • Last Login: 2013-09-07 09:19:51
  • Forum Info: Profile        Posts (1)
  • Usefulness: 133.4 with 146 opinions
    [average 119.3 of 231971 opinions; standard deviation 432 ]
  • Profile: How I Evaluate AMVs

    Originality
    ----------
    I base this on several factors: the AMV style, the song & anime combination, and the presentation.


    Visual
    ----------
    I enjoy watching AMV at the highest resolution possible, preferably full-screen. In this way, one is able to appreciate the individual nuances throughout video.


    Sound
    ----------
    Based upon the overall quality of the song itself. Usually given a high score unless: the quality is poor the or the original anime can still be heard in background.


    Synch
    ----------
    For me this is a combination of the scene selection, pacing of video with song, and how the lyrics play off the video and vices versa.


    Lip
    ----------


    Effects
    ----------
    Are they flashy, just for the sake of being flashy or do they serve a greater purpose to add something that otherwise would not have been there without them.


    Effort
    ----------
    This is hard to determine. However, for starters I examine how detailed it looks. Does it look like the creator tried his/her best, based on previous works and the AMV itself. For example, I have seen some AMVs where the creator clearly put a lot of effort into parts of the AMV, but then not so with rest of the AMV.


    Re-View
    ----------


    Overall
    ----------


    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    Please note: Replies for opinions I give are greatly appreciated. Let me know if I missed something or didn't understand what you were trying to express through your AMV.

global average

  • Count231971
  • Originality8.47
  • Visual Quality8.37
  • Audio9.00
  • Action Sync8.45
  • Lip Sync8.24
  • Special Effects8.49
  • Effort8.60
  • Re-view-ability7.92
  • Overall8.43

average given

  • Count146
  • Originality9.01
  • Visual Quality9.19
  • Audio9.34
  • Action Sync9.34
  • Lip Sync9.09
  • Special Effects9.46
  • Effort9.32
  • Re-view-ability8.62
  • Overall8.82

average received

  • Count0
  • Originality
  • Visual Quality
  • Audio
  • Action Sync
  • Lip Sync
  • Special Effects
  • Effort
  • Re-view-ability
  • Overall