(The Reason) Why?

Minion · Post by **Minion** » Wed Jul 11, 2007 12:20 pm

my only peeves:
that was a seagull
"the end" font sucks

Warheart · Post by **Warheart** » Wed Jul 11, 2007 12:25 pm

Gah, this video nearly made me fall asleep. Sorry Ingo but this one is a bit to slow for me and I can't stand the music it's just to sappy. Better luck with your connichi video.

Esrhan · Post by **Esrhan** » Wed Jul 11, 2007 12:32 pm

I seriously did not like the song at all, but I saw what you were going for with the lyric synch.

Jnzk · Post by **Jnzk** » Wed Jul 11, 2007 12:36 pm

It's a keeper.

-GfN- · Post by **-GfN-** » Wed Jul 11, 2007 1:06 pm

I kinda agree with alex here. not particularly against old school editing but this couldn't catch my attention for too long. rather good editing tho so 6.5/10

~Jannis

yumi+chan · Post by **yumi+chan** » Wed Jul 11, 2007 3:52 pm

I think this is one of your more enjoyable videos^^
I think it's quite nice, but a little bit boring too due to the song

omegaevolution · Post by **omegaevolution** » Wed Jul 11, 2007 8:08 pm

well I'm not to fond to old school but I liked how this AMV was made, nice scene selection and overall a pretty good editing that really drag me in. The only bad thing that I could point is that the song was too constant and long which made the AMV a bit boring after a while.

Overall I liked it

4/5

CrackTheSky · Post by **CrackTheSky** » Thu Jul 12, 2007 12:46 am

Minion wrote:"the end" font sucks

True dat. Interesting video though, especially because I happen to be making a video with Jin Roh footage at the moment. I really liked the concept, and the song was a cool choice to fit it. Good stuff all around, although nothing particularly mindblowing. 4/5

Ingow · Post by **Ingow** » Thu Jul 12, 2007 11:06 am

I appreciate the feedback guys

Minion wrote: that was a seagull

yah, well, I know...but...I bet you could see it as a kind of metaphor anyway? or something like that? :p

Warheart wrote:Gah, this video nearly made me fall asleep. Sorry Ingo but this one is a bit to slow for me and I can't stand the music it's just to sappy. Better luck with your connichi video.

My connichi video is me trying out AE and adding random cutouts (but at least on a song I like). Still if it comes any way near the first three places in any kind of way I swear I'll quit editing.

Oh and dude, I know what you're usually into so believe me you weren't exactly the target audience for this one ;> Y'know I'm not forcing you to download and comment on everything I make

Esrhan wrote:I seriously did not like the song at all, but I saw what you were going for with the lyric synch.

That's good because that makes out like 50% of what the video is about :>

Janzki wrote:It's a keeper.

I am honored :O

-Good for Nothing- wrote:I kinda agree with alex here. not particularly against old school editing but this couldn't catch my attention for too long. rather good editing tho so 6.5/10

~Jannis

Man, that's still a pretty high score you gave me there for not really liking it, thanks ;>

yumi+chan wrote:I think this is one of your more enjoyable videos^^
I think it's quite nice, but a little bit boring too due to the song

thx, and well, i can only work with the music I like :>

omegaevolution wrote:well I'm not to fond to old school but I liked how this AMV was made, nice scene selection and overall a pretty good editing that really drag me in. The only bad thing that I could point is that the song was too constant and long which made the AMV a bit boring after a while.

Overall I liked it
4/5

Thanks, especially for mentioning the scene selection since it has a lot of thought put into it. And yes, the song is definately not very much helping the video but it's not really an AMV that's supposed to be all that enjoyable (in the meaning of jumping up and down), seeing as it's pretty dark and all

CrackTheSky wrote:
Minion wrote:"the end" font sucks
True dat.

Yeah yeah, I admit it, I did not take the time to find a new font on the net that would fit this particular case but honestly whenever I make an AMV all of my fonts on my PC seem to start sucking instantly for some reason :p

CrackTheSky wrote: Interesting video though, especially because I happen to be making a video with Jin Roh footage at the moment. I really liked the concept, and the song was a cool choice to fit it. Good stuff all around, although nothing particularly mindblowing. 4/5

Thanks, it's way too personal to be mindblowing in general and I understand that. It's just that I really like this kind of music and especially in this case my focus was more on representing the spirit of the song as intended by Joan Baez more than releasing some kind of ultimate AMV.