THE "UNEARTHED" PROJECT!

Pie Row Maniac · Post by **Pie Row Maniac** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 5:01 pm

jethropr wrote:
Pie Row Maniac wrote:Track 8 - This one blows my mind o_O Awesome editing but a bit overwhelming. My personal favorite track.
wow pie, I'm honored

Actually that was aimed at the Gungrave track.

damnit did I get the track numbers mixed up?

angelx03 · Post by **angelx03** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 5:03 pm

The Gungrave track was Track 9, and that's done by kisanzi.

Pie Row Maniac · Post by **Pie Row Maniac** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 5:20 pm

Ohhh I forgot the Arjuna track. Geez aren't I the heel...

jethropr · Post by **jethropr** » Thu Nov 24, 2005 6:40 am

MY WORLD HAS BEEN CRUSHED!!!!!

*inverse* · Post by ***inverse*** » Thu Nov 24, 2005 12:16 pm

Quick comments:

Track #01 - Very pretty - definitely one of my favorite parts. I love the use of layers.
Track #02 - I like this one. It's simple and it flows together nicely.
Track #03 - I don't like the Animatrix, but I think Prodigi did an excellent job with it - everything is timed up perfectly, and I like the effects used at the end.
Track #04 - This is another movie I don't really care for, but the track was well done. The intensity of the music matched with the scenes used.
Track #05 - I've never heard of this anime before - the sync could probably be a little tighter, but I enjoyed it overall.
Track #06 - This track seemed a little jumpy, but I do like the scene selection at the beginning.
Track #07 - I really liked the second half of this video - flowed together nicely.
Track #08 - Whenever I hear this track, it reminds me of gardens and flowers and what not, so it was really nice to see that used. I haven't seen this anime, but I really enjoyed this track - especially the ending.
Track #09 - I love the effects! This track is lot's of fun to watch. Excellent job on this one, kisanzi.
Track #10 - Hmm... yay for sexy ninja angst!
Track #11 - I haven't seen this anime, but the track was pretty well done considering the amount of time Vega Sailor had to work on it.
Track #12 - This track is a little slow for my tastes, but I do love that bit of angst in the end.
(angst is always good

)
Track #13 - This is a fun track. Nicely timed up.
Track #14 - My other favorite track. A great ending for the project!

I'm really impressed at how great this turned out. Vega Sailor did an excellent job organizing this. I joined in the project late, so I didn't have as much time to work on my track. But considering that this was my first multi-editor project, I had fun. I actually went and bought the CD after listening to the mix

Overall, great job everyone

Pie Row Maniac · Post by **Pie Row Maniac** » Sat Nov 26, 2005 2:45 pm

Fixed >_>

Track 1 (Vega Sailor) - Great transparency work, one of my favorite tracks
Track 2 (Fate Bringer) - Could've been a little sharper on the timing but I still enjoyed it
Track 3 (Prodigi) - Great timing and effects. I liked this one.
Track 4 (Que?) - OMG SUCKED!!1 >_>
Track 5 (angelx03) - Awkward timing but good action
Track 6 (Supersaiyan313) - Good editing and almost all the scenes fit the mood perfectly
Track 7 (Marco) - Some of the sadder scenes in the beginning didn't fit the song to me and the anime could've been fixed up quality-wise but I really liked the later part with the other song
Track 8 (Jethro) - Very pretty. The editing was done nicely (the world is not egg-shaped!

) but the video made me feel pleasent and made me smile.
Track 9 (Kisanzi) - This one blows my mind o_O Awesome editing but a bit overwhelming. My personal favorite track.
Track 10 (inverse) - I really liked the effects used. There was obviously a story element involved but I had a hard time understanding what it was.
Track 11 (Vega Sailor) - Interesting anime choice. Effects were nice but there was some small timing issues at the very end.
Track 12 (Scoob) - Not to be harsh but it was kinda boring. Most of the editing was decent but I think a different anime would have worked better.
Track 13 (OtakuForLife) - Great action and timing but too many spoilers

Track 14 (BigDude) - A good ending to the project. Editing and effects were nicely done but I wouldn't ditched the white lines that appeared frequently.

Yar, now everyone is satisfied.

Scoob · Post by **Scoob** » Sat Nov 26, 2005 7:09 pm

*inverse* wrote:Quick comments:

Track #12 - This track is a little slow for my tastes, but I do love that bit of angst in the end.
(angst is always good )

Overall, great job everyone

Pie Row Maniac wrote:
Track 12 (Scoob) - Not to be harsh but it was kinda boring. Most of the editing was decent but I think a different anime would have worked better.

Thanks for the honest opinions it's great help.

I had fun working on the track and great work everyone. Nice job putting it together Vega Sailor.

Vega Sailor · Post by **Vega Sailor** » Sun Nov 27, 2005 5:20 pm

Do you guys (participants) have access to opinions left for the "Unearthed Project?

*inverse* · Post by ***inverse*** » Sun Nov 27, 2005 6:26 pm

Vega Sailor wrote:Do you guys (participants) have access to opinions left for the "Unearthed Project?

No - unless we each leave an opinion, I think you'll be the only one who gets to see them.

Yorae · Post by **Yorae** » Mon Nov 28, 2005 7:49 am

Great job on this MEP , Even though I felt that there was great different in pace and editting involvement between some of the tracks, it all worked out together into an enjoyable big picture. This is a very well done tribute to the band^_^ The editors should give themselves a good pat of the back for this one ^_^

My favourite tracks are 1, 3,9 and 11