Gotta say, I was really excited seeing the beta for this, and I like the way it turned out in the end.
*Flow/editing was actually pretty well done. The story comes across fairly nicely and as somebody that hasn't seen the anime, I was able to quickly pick it up and understand everything going on. I liked the combination between the "dark world" and the "light world" and the transitioning between them.
*Conceptually pretty nice. I haven't seen much like it, and I've seen like a million youtube videos with this thing in the last week, and this one seems to tell it fairly well. [/needs to watch this anime apparently, since every editor under the youtube sun is hitting it up]
*Video quality is as good as one could hope for.
*Flicker at :23 was still kind of off, but much improved upon. The flicker effect overall was still much improved upon, but I'm still on the fence about it.
*I feel that towards the end there were some wonky shaking and scenes a tad too long
. I also think the colored in backgrounds instead of the white ones, while a ton better than what you originally had, could still have had actual anime footage there and had some better feel to it.
*I was kind of sad about its length. I'd have much more preferred a little more length and more character development, but as is, it's still fairly well done in a condensed manner.
*To be honest, I couldn't really see the koop or nostromo in this, and I think that's a good thing. It's important to develop your own unique style in editing, and while using another as a base and finding your own direction is fine, make sure and retain your individuality.
Generally, very enjoyable. I think you've found your niche' in editing. Glad to see improvements, and can't wait to see it develop further.
4.75/5.00