Post
by Keeper of Hellfire » Fri Sep 29, 2006 7:55 am
To deserve a 1 a vid must be really crappy. Bad footage, bad (qualitywise) music, no concept, really bad synching. Amongst the AMV's that I donwloaded was none that bad.
Enhancing the star scale to zero would possibly spread the range a bit and lower the medium score. But it would be unfair for new AMV's compared with already rated ones. That way the old stars had to be adjusted, what would be unfair either, or there had to be made a break old/new stars.
I'm fine with the distribution of the stars as it is. You must be aware that not 3.0 stars marks the middle like you might expect from a 1...5 rating, it's 3.5. If you look at the distribution of the stars, it drops very fast below 4.0, and a really wide range is 3.5 +/- 0.3 marking the average ones, and the drop below 3.0 happens close to the end. So the distribution curve is a bit squished, but in order.