Remember, this is only my opinion.
The Good: an Okay first vid, not the best by any means, but still not bad. It was a little enjoyable, so it's good, just not excelent. Some of your beats were dead on like 1:10-1:11, but usually it wouldn't last too long (for example: 1:12-1:15 could have used more attention on the action synch) But I have to tell you, 1:21-1:15 fit perfectly. Good job on that. 1:37-1:46 was good too, but the frame of naruto at (late) 1:37 detracted from it. 2:02-2:05 was okay, but you repeated scenes after that, wich was annoying. 2:41-2:43 seemed bad at first, until I saw the huge climax at 2:44-2:48 which brought it together, but even that culd have been better. I understand making that scene last so long, but a fade at the end would have topped it off perfectly in my opinion. There were othe good parts too, but these stood out the most to me.
The Bad: It had a DivX Logo, and Subtitles. try to avoid that in the future. It had no real story, which would have been acceptable since it's action, and action doesn't need story, but unfortunately, you completely missed some synch, but then again, you hit some perfectly, so that was a lot of hit and miss. Some areas were flat outconfusing from jumping around too much though. I'd suggest trying to focus on one character or preferably one fight per "climax." Some areas like 0:46-0:48 were jumpy, which was distracting, same for clips that were too short like at 0:48. I suggest working hardewr at making clips hit the major beats better. some actions came almost a second afetr the last major beat, which took me out of the experience. 1:47-2:00 needed more work, it didn't really keep with the music, and the quick chage of fights at 2:01 completely removed me from the experience. 2:06-2:22 was jumpy, and hard to pay attention to. Even slow sections need synch. 2:23 was just wierd though, and 2:24-2:26 was heavily pixelated and seemed out of place. There was more as well, but all of that are basically the same problem.
The ugly: No offense, but the quality was bad (sub par at best, though there were some acceptable parts). Even wth WMM, you can have better image quality. It was acceptable, but painful for anything bigger than the original size. Pixelation became very noticable in some areas, but I won't hold that aganst you too much since this was a first vid
Overall: 4.9 out of 10 (with 5 being average, no school grading). Good at times,but bad to sub-par at others, but the subtitle and DivX logos need to go (along with the pixelation). Try getting some DVD footage instead of downladed footage next time as well. In conclusion:
_______________________________________

__
Good First vid_____________