First AMV

Rozard · Post by **Rozard** » Wed Oct 15, 2003 11:21 am

Wow, this was really good. Very good for a first video. I don't see how it's mostly about Asuka. I thought you did a great job dividing the song evenly between Asuka, Rei and Misato. At any rate, I really like it, endorse it, and I can't wait to see something else by you

Grinsekatze · Post by **Grinsekatze** » Wed Oct 15, 2003 11:39 am

Scintilla wrote: (But I used the command-line FTP client instead of that WebFTP thing you had that link go to, because I couldn't find any "Upload" button, and besides, it was all in German, even after I changed the language to English. Nothing against German, it's just that I can't read it.)

well done! thanks for the upload, you got a wish for free now xD

i posted a link to the ftp, but i made the misstake with the "http" anyway thanks.. the ftpdata will be "censored" now..

Grinsekatze · Post by **Grinsekatze** » Wed Oct 15, 2003 4:39 pm

hi, here is my opinion:

I like it pretty much, if i had 100 other AMVs yours would be at, approximatly the 20th place.

The Song is a pretty good choice. the timing to the beat and lyrics is mostly good work. i have to say that i like the scenes at the end more as the scenes at the beginning. in the middle it reaches a very good level (like the scene with the 2 viewpoints in the center, where the redhaired girl is in the bigger frame.. the start shouldnt use the same song as in the main part, i think.. the codec is average, resolution could be better.. but its ok, as in the most other vids.

tnx for the song!

bye
Matthias

Flint the Dwarf · Post by **Flint the Dwarf** » Wed Oct 15, 2003 7:52 pm

Thanks to Roz for the heads up ^_^.

Very nice, Cyanna. Much respect. I can't discredit you for using Eva, it's what I used for my first and only video. I disagree with Lyrs though (for once

), about it being mostly about Asuka. I thought it was very evenly distributed and I liked it very much.

I love to see more creators focus so much on the plot of the video instead of getting caught up so much in just the visual editing.

Keep up the good work and I'd love to see more from you in the future. I'm going to put this in my pile of potential videos to review, especially because it's your first and I love Eva, but it takes me hours to review thoroughly.