Oh yes. I knew when watching the early betas that you'd hit the mood of the song perfectly, and the final product was no exception..
I'll be obviously biased because I love the song, but I'll be honest and say that I've never really ever liked Air. But this was ADORABLE! What's best is that the video sort of painted a new picture of Air, if not a completely different story all together. In fact, people don't even have to have ever seen Air to get the story/concept behind this one, which is hard to accomplish in AMV's.
But then again, your strongest asset [or at least in my opinion] is your ability to tell a creative story with anime and not be shackled down by the anime's original storyline.
So concept, editing and sync were all top notch.. That being said, the obvious issue is still visual quality. There were black borders on both sides, and Air is best viewed in 16:9, but that being said, you definitely improved in the visual quality department from your past videos.

So while I COULD complain about it, the visual quality wasn't distracting to the overall enjoyment of the video, so I can't complain too much.
Oh, and the part with Benji the Dog? I vote that the CUTEST part of any AMV I've seen in 4 years. xD
4.5/5 easily. And definitely my new favorite work from you [Knocked "Ouran Not Pretending" off it's high horse FINALLY xD].
[Also, I need to get my butt to work on a country video as soon as I finish the SFIV MEP. XD]