Hey TreeTheTreeAMV wrote:Good god, people. Seriously, I thought this trailer was great. Good lipsync is damn near impossible with CGI footage. The character's don't totally line up - so what? If you hadn't seen the Matrix, you wouldn't even know that Mr. Anderson and Neo were the same person. I liked that he mixed it up. I liked that he messed with a lot of the conventions of AMV making in the process.
And before anyone bashes me for not being a great editor... are you kidding me? What happened to making AMVs for fun? They're supposed to be entertaining. This one was.
In summary: if you have a problem with this video, I would recommend you jump off your AMV-making high-horse and take your laptop out of your behind.
(This was rant-like. I apologize. I'm just a bit frustrated with the AMV making community right now. And if you are not one of the jerks, this is not directed at you.)

Also, when I post a video here, I expect a critique. I specifically post my videos here because I like that there are people here more skilled than me who are willing to give feedback. Heck some people wouldn't have posted a critique, if they didnt think that the video had any potential.
Also Tree, no one here is going to say your opinion isnt valid because 'you're a good editor or not'. We dont really have that fanboyish element here. Some of the main critics here actually dont edit.
Nice to see you post here. I also noticed that some of the other members of your studio are getting into this site, too. Stick around a bit and get used to it. I'm sure you'll like it.