Gidra - Rumble in the New York

[blabbler]

This Video is horrofying.

You destroyed, no, you absolutely murdered one of my favourite songs of all time.

I swear to God, If I stood right in front of you, I'd

i was only the other day speculating on whether you are really all cuddles and teddy bears in real life. i'm kind of beginning to lean towards the 'kev is a total dick' hypothesis.

edit:

video was fun, but the camera moves seemed really twitchy and uncontrolled, there's no depth either (especially at 45s, what's up with that?), it never 'looks' like more than 2d layers and a camera fizzing along, i think it would be greatly improved if you worked on the newspapers to make them look a bit more paper-like. paper has loads of texture up close, so does newsprint. i like the low framerate action O:

[Ingow]

i was only the other day speculating on whether you are really all cuddles and teddy bears in real life. i'm kind of beginning to lean towards the 'kev is a total dick' hypothesis.

so basically you want him to lie?

it's not like the positive criticism in this thread was very deep and thoughtful, so why the heck should negative criticism have to be.

Gidra himself doesn't really hold back on that over here either.

[blabbler]

so basically you want him to lie?

it's not like the positive criticism in this thread was very deep and thoughtful, so why the heck should negative criticism have to be.

Gidra himself doesn't really hold back on that over here either.

O: so i'm take what kev said literally, rather than as incredibly childish? if that's the case it's totally indefensible |:

[Ingow]

O: so i'm take what kev said literally, rather than as incredibly childish? if that's the case it's totally indefensible |:

someone should explain the concept of insulting people over the internet to you
also having a temper and cursing a lot is every old fisherman's right

[blabbler]

I swear to God, If I stood right in front of you, I'd cut you with a fucking razorblade.

i feel old today :/







but i lyke fishermen

[Vivaldi]

It was enjoyable, but it had some big problems. far too much focus on the text, the parts where you just did straight baccano were best. As blabbler said the camera is far to erratic. There was several times where the scenes had no relation to... anything. Also, slight grammer problem. it should be "Rumble in NY", not rumble in the NY. Other than that however, the action scenes went pretty well. And the frame skip thing you did alot was quite interesting.

[LeapofFate]

It didn't focus on the song, the atmosphere, the mood, the anime or its characters. The main focus was on effects and your own plot and concept, which was barely even there.

x2

I liked the editing in general, but Ingow pretty much summed up what I thought.

[Gidrasan]

thx all for opinion... i'm glad that you enjoy this vid, and if you didn't enjoy - i can understand you =)

This Video is horrofying.

You destroyed, no, you absolutely murdered one of my favourite songs of all time.

I swear to God, If I stood right in front of you, I'd cut you with a fucking razorblade.

I love you too, my darling

video was fun, but the camera moves seemed really twitchy and uncontrolled, there's no depth either (especially at 45s, what's up with that?), it never 'looks' like more than 2d layers and a camera fizzing along, i think it would be greatly improved if you worked on the newspapers to make them look a bit more paper-like. paper has loads of texture up close, so does newsprint. i like the low framerate action O:

I agree with you... in next time i'll trying fix my mistakes in 3D

So basically you just copied every effect/style method that has already been successful in a russian AMV in the past, put them all into one video and that's supposed to make it good, right?

No, really O.o... and in what russian amv this effects has already been?

[Ingow]

and in what russian amv this effects has already been?

most obvious one:



changing the good old comic/manga effect to a newspaper also doesn't really make a difference.

[Odissey]

Ingow

absolutely different effects and different styles