All Time Eliminator! Results and Stats!

[Madpierrot]

Three long and hard fought eliminators have been complete. I'd have that we know have a good view of what people on this board truely consider the greats. Thanks once again for everyone who voted, I had a lot of fun doing this and seeing the results and I hope you guys did as well. Sorry it took so long for this, but after a long wait the winner of the All Time Eliminator was...

NEON GENESIS EVANGELION (fancy music)
It was a very very close vote 10 - 9 over the winner of the greatest anime eliminator Cowboy Bebop. What a shocker. Also third place went to... Azumanga Daioh over Kenshin OVA by a score of 10 - 6. Seems that Azumanga was the only newer show that people really seemed to vote for.

Now some stats from the past 3 eliminators:
Neon Genesis Evangelion got a 1st and 2nd place finish, 3 elite 8 appearances
Cowboy Bebop got a 1st and 2nd place finish, 3 elite 8 appearances
Azumanga Daioh got a 1st and 3rd place finish, 3 elite 8 appearances
Kenshin OVA got a 3rd and 4th place finish, 2 elite 8 appearances
FLCL got a 4th place finish, 2 elite 8 appearances
Love Hina got a 2nd place finish, 1 elite 8 appearance
Inu Yasha got a 3rd place finish, 1 elite 8 appearance
Naruto got a 4th place finish, 1 elite 8 appearance
Escaflowne got 2 elite 8 appearances
Akira got 2 elite 8 appearances
His and Her Circumstances got 2 elite 8 appearances

Top 4 vote getters were:
Neon Genesis Evangelion 130
Cowboy Bebop 126
Azumanga Daioh 117
Kenshin OVA 82

Most votes in one round:
Round 2 (all time eliminator)
Neon Genesis Evangelion 24

Biggest win:
Round 2 (greatest anime)
2) Cowboy Bebop (Sci-Fi) 15 got 100% (only shutout)
18) Tenchi Muyo (Romance) 0
Round 2 (all time eliminator)
6) Escaflowne 4
2) Neon Genesis Evangelion 24 won by 20 (largest margin)


Complete Recap
Great Anime Ever
1st Round
1) Neon Genesis Evangelion (Mech) 12
32) Slayers (Fantasy) 4

16) Grave of Fireflies (Drama) 4
17) Princess Mononoke (Fantasy) 12

5) Kenshin OVA (Action) 13
28) Perfect Blue (Drama) 2

12) Kenshin TV (Action) 8
21) Millennium Actress (Drama) 8

8) Ninja Scroll (Action) 8
25) Revolutionary Girl Utena (?) 8

9) Ghost in a Shell (Sci-Fi) 9
24) Lupin the 3rd (Comedy) 6

13) His and Her Circumstances (Romance) 11
20) Ranma ½ (Comedy) 5

4) Excel Saga (Comedy) 10
29) Berserk (Fantasy) 6

2) Cowboy Bebop (Sci-Fi) 13
31) Fruits Basket (Romance/Comedy) 2

15) Sailor Moon (Romance) 6
18) Tenchi Muyo (Romance) 10

11) FLCL (hard to say, Action) 15
22) Vampire Princess Miyu (Horror) 1

6) Gundam Wing (Mech) 4
27) Serial Experiment Lain (Sci-Fi) 12

7) Akira (Sci-Fi) 8
26) Ah! My Goddess (Romance) 8

10) Macross Plus (Mech) 11
23) Mobile Suit Gundam (Mech) 5

14) Fushigi Yugi (Romance) 12
19) DragonBall Z (Action) 4

3) Escaflowne (Fantasy) 13
30) Card Captor Sakura (Adventure) 3

2nd Round
1) Neon Genesis Evangelion (Mech) 12
17) Princess Mononoke (Fantasy) 3

9) Ghost in a Shell (Sci-Fi) 8
25) Revolutionary Girl Utena (?) 7

5) Kenshin OVA (Action) 10
21) Millennium Actress (Drama) 5

13) His and Her Circumstances (Romance) 10
4) Excel Saga (Comedy) 5

2) Cowboy Bebop (Sci-Fi) 15
18) Tenchi Muyo (Romance) 0

7) Akira (Sci-Fi) 9
10) Macross Plus (Mech) 6

11) FLCL (hard to say, Action) 10
27) Serial Experiment Lain (Sci-Fi) 5

14) Fushigi Yugi (Romance) 5
3) Escaflowne (Fantasy) 10

3rd Round
1) Neon Genesis Evangelion (Mech) 18
9) Ghost in a Shell (Sci-Fi) 1

5) Kenshin OVA (Action) 10
13) His and Her Circumstances (Romance) 9

2) Cowboy Bebop (Sci-Fi) 18
7) Akira (Sci-Fi) 1

11) FLCL (hard to say, Action) 13
3) Escaflowne (Fantasy) 6

4th Round
1) Neon Genesis Evangelion (Mech) 14
5) Kenshin OVA (Action) 4

2) Cowboy Bebop (Sci-Fi) 14
11) FLCL (hard to say, Action) 4

1st - Cowboy Bebop
2nd - Neon Genesis
3rd - Kenshin OVA
4th - FLCL




Recent anime eliminator
Round 1
1) Inu Yasha (Fantasy, Action) 11
32) Jin-Roh (Drama) 7

16) Noir ("mild" Action) 7
17) Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust (Action, Horror) 11

8) GTO (Comedy) 8
25) X (Action) 10

9) RaXephon (Mech) 13
24) Blood the last vampire (Horror) 5

12) S-Cry-Ed (Action) 13
21) Initial D (Action) 5

5) Love Hina (Comedy, Romance) 16
28) Ai Yori Aoshi (Romance) 2

13) Blue Gender (Sci-Fi, Horror) 10
20) Big O (Mech) 8

4) Hellsing (Horror) 17
29) Samurai Deeper Kyo (Action) 1


2) Naruto (Action) 12
31) Voices from a distant star (Drama) 6

15) Wolfs Rain (Action) 11
18) .Hack/Sign (Fantasy) 7

10) Vandread (Sci-Fi, Action) 10
23) Ghost in a Shell SAC (Sci-Fi) 9

7) Read or Die (Action) 13
26) Please Twins (Romance) 5

11) Witch Hunter Robin (Drama) 15
22) Gundam Seed (Mech) 3

6) Spirited away (Fantasy) 10
27) Haibana Renmei (Drama) 8

14) Please Teacher (Romance) 8
19) Chobits (Comedy, Romance) 10

3) Azumanga Diaoh (Comedy) 16
30) Ninja Scroll TV (Action) 2


Round 2
1) Inu Yasha (Fantasy, Action) 9
17) Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust (Action, Horror) 7

25) X (Action) 9
9) RaXephon (Mech) 7

12) S-Cry-Ed (Action) 6
5) Love Hina (Comedy, Romance) 10

13) Blue Gender (Sci-Fi, Horror) 5
4) Hellsing (Horror) 11


2) Naruto (Action) 9
15) Wolfs Rain (Action) 7

10) Vandread (Sci-Fi, Action) 5
7) Read or Die (Action) 11

11) Witch Hunter Robin (Drama) 9
6) Spirited away (Fantasy) 7

19) Chobits (Comedy, Romance) 5
3) Azumanga Diaoh (Comedy) 11


Round 3
1) Inu Yasha (Fantasy, Action) 16
25) X (Action) 9

5) Love Hina (Comedy, Romance) 16
4) Hellsing (Horror) 8


2) Naruto (Action) 16
7) Read or Die (Action) 8

11) Witch Hunter Robin (Drama) 8
3) Azumanga Diaoh (Comedy) 17


Round 4
1) Inu Yasha (Fantasy, Action) 10
5) Love Hina (Comedy, Romance) 11


2) Naruto (Action) 6
3) Azumanga Diaoh (Comedy) 15


1st - Azumanga Diaoh
2nd - Love Hina
3rd - Inu Yasha
4th - Naruto


All Time Eliminator
Round 1
1) Azumanga Daioh 13
8) Ghost in the Shell 8

4) FLCL 12
5) Hellsing 9

3) Inu Yasha 9
6) Escaflowne 12

2) Neon Genesis Evangelion 15
7) X 6


2) Love Hina 7
7) Akira 14

3) Kenshin OVA 13
6) Read or Die 8

4) Naruto 9
5) His and Her Circumstances 12

1) Cowboy Bebop 19
8) Whitch Hunter Robin 2


Round 2
1))Azumanga Daioh 15
4) FLCL 13

6) Escaflowne 4
2) Neon Genesis Evangelion 24

7) Akira 13
3) Kenshin OVA 15

5) His and Her Circumstances 11
1) Cowboy Bebop 16


Round 3
1) Azumanga Daioh 4
2) Neon Genesis Evangelion 12

3) Kenshin OVA 3
1) Cowboy Bebop 13


The Final
2) Neon Genesis Evangelion 10
1) Cowboy Bebop 9

1) Azumanga Daioh 10
3) Kenshin OVA 6


Phew!, Ah! Finally all done. Well I hope you discuss, complain, argue, brag, or just think I'm crazy for doing this, whatever it is I hope you enjoy:)

[Otohiko]

Heh, cool, though I think by the time CB and Eva ended up among the picks in semi-finals, it just got too darn obvious - that is, that they would end up doing combat in the finals, and the winner would sort of be decided on luck; both great titles, both equally deserving... So, whichever way it went, all good. My vote won, so I'm happier still

I think we need a more obscure eliminator now - maybe since we had a recent anime one, now we need an 'old'/classic anime eliminator?

[ReannaKing]

Ugh, why did Slayers drop out so soon? Makes me sad.

[HeartbreakerByZep]

Wonderful fun it 'twas. Thanks for the stats and everything too, that was interesting.

[AMVfreak]

Wonderful fun it 'twas. Thanks for the stats and everything too, that was interesting.

x2
That was fun to do. Thanks Madpierrot.
Hopefully we'll see more later in the future with different styles like Oto said.

[SSJVegita0609]

You all have horrible taste

(omg jk)

[Master Shake]

Another good eliminator, I love how you put out all the stats for all of the eliminators. I guess this just shows that Cowboy Bebop and Eva are clearly the fan favorites.

[angelx03]

Another good eliminator, I love how you put out all the stats for all of the eliminators. I guess this just shows that Cowboy Bebop and Eva are clearly the fan favorites.

In a voluntarily sense then yes.

[Merm]

Thanks for doing the eliminator, always exciting. Especially Eva v. CB. Damn good fight!