Godspeed(BT)

[Elcalavero]

Dude. Awful. Not only did you completely butcher and destroy the soul of one of my favorite BT songs, none of the scenes had anything in common with each other. Some people can get away with zero concept and storytelling if the editing is good enough, but in this case just doing flashes and rapid cuts to sync to the beats simply doesn't do it. I know you put this together in less than a day, but you really, REALLY could have put more effort into it and taken more time to think of more creative things to do.

1/5

this

[Inan]

Nostromo needs to change his style to throw off all the copycat attempts.

I agree with all the comments above.

How am I copying his style?

[AceD]

i thought it was decent to watch 3/5 for me..but i do like Air alot to , if thats 1/5 i dont think ill ever post a video once ive finnished learning

[Vivaldi]

Nostromo needs to change his style to throw off all the copycat attempts.

I agree with all the comments above.

How am I copying his style?

You used a trance song and footage that didn't have crappy animation.


I found it to be a pleasant, if forgettable, experience.

[Inan]

Haha thanks guys if anything I will take most of these comments into consideration when I make my next amv

[bladedude101]

I thought this was pretty good


433/787

[-Reda-]

Dude. Awful. Not only did you completely butcher and destroy the soul of one of my favorite BT songs, none of the scenes had anything in common with each other. Some people can get away with zero concept and storytelling if the editing is good enough, but in this case just doing flashes and rapid cuts to sync to the beats simply doesn't do it. I know you put this together in less than a day, but you really, REALLY could have put more effort into it and taken more time to think of more creative things to do.

1/5

this

[hasteroth]

Dude. Awful. Not only did you completely butcher and destroy the soul of one of my favorite BT songs, none of the scenes had anything in common with each other. Some people can get away with zero concept and storytelling if the editing is good enough, but in this case just doing flashes and rapid cuts to sync to the beats simply doesn't do it. I know you put this together in less than a day, but you really, REALLY could have put more effort into it and taken more time to think of more creative things to do.

1/5

this

Quoted Image converted to link:
http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/3237/6 ... 030240.jpg

I'd give Reda about a day...

[Pas]

Yue summed it up pretty accurately for me.

You hacked the song down and it was just random pretty scenes to an awesome song that was cut to a sad length. It was pointless and there was nothing special about it to make it stand out from the thousands of other videos with the exact same sources and the exact same plot (NONE).

While I don't quite agree it warrented a 1/5, I do think that there was nothing really captivating about this. The editing was pretty standard, and I'll be blunt, those initial fade in/outs damn well hurt my eyes. They weren't needed and you could have blended them together a lot more smoothly, even if (and I know you were going for this) you wanted to have a clear sync point. There was a lack of anything to follow, be it scene selection or story. Because of this I hardly cared what it was that I was seeing. Even maintaining a small sense of flow would have greatly helped spark a little bit of interest in this, make the viewer look forward to something. There was nothing.

It was the slow parts of this AMV which redeemed it in my eyes. They weren't great, but they seemed tenfold better than when you were trying to sync every scene to a sound when the beat picked up. Overall a 2.5/5, I didn't hate it, but there was a lot more you could have done to make me like it. Hopefully you'll take these things into account next time, and I look forward to your improvement.

[JadeCharm]

that certain something of a good trance video was missing.
i like the beginning, but the rest was a little bit boring.
think it was because you used too much scenes of the same anime in a row e.g. the Air-part

3/5