A Road Of Few Productions Project

Discussion & organization of Multi-Editor Projects
Locked
User avatar
Infinity Squared
Mr. Poopy Pants
Joined: Wed Aug 11, 2004 10:07 pm
Status: Shutting Down
Location: Australia
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by Infinity Squared » Wed Feb 22, 2006 11:50 pm

AMV Heaven is taken or at least is an idea used by someone else already (though not about Christian music :P).

Sorry as well if I sounded like I was saying this idea was bad. Honestly, I think it's a good idea and wouldn't have bothered posting if I didn't want to see it happen and come into fruition in a good way. But yeah, I was just afraid it'll end up mediocre or not at all if we don't have a better set of guidelines to work with.

Hmm... I have to look at my collection once more for a good song :P I've been listening to too much JPop lately :lol:

I like Sierra's suggestion :D

And we might get more people interested too :P
Image

User avatar
Osakaisthebomb
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2005 5:05 pm
Status: 16 kib limit is a crime.
Location: Florence,Alabama
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by Osakaisthebomb » Thu Feb 23, 2006 12:19 am

Sierra Lorna, I apprciate the gesture but I don't think it's for the right reason. Please have some faith in me for a change. I will finish this project. This isn't going to get canceled I assure you that. Like I said before I have chosen to work with sora764. Why? Well for one thing I know the dude. Another is that he lives in the same town as I do now so working on it together would be simple and I have learned aobut encoding and will be working on that with another friend of mine.

Also I don't like the idea of giving this project to anyone else. I don't mean to sound slefish on this but if I did that I would have no right to call it my own. Plus there is the chance that the ideas and direction I want to take this might be different than yours.

Sierra, please I need to do this on my own. I'm sorry but I have to decline your offer.

Also, what info about this project am I not clearifying? Please explain. This would help alot.

User avatar
silver_moon
Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2001 12:46 pm
Location: British Columbia, Canada
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by silver_moon » Thu Feb 23, 2006 12:50 am

In your first post you just sounded a bit unsure of yourself and how the project would turn out, so that had both Sierra and I worried. Now you say you're going to finish the project, but it seems like you're not letting the rest of us in on the plan you have for it, or that you just haven't thought about some things yet.
- How long are you planning on making this?
- What's it even going to be called?
- What kind of transitions do you have planned?
- Are you going to set any other kind of standards? Would you let a track that is barely edited into the project? Would you disqualify tracks that came with extremely poor audio/video quality?

The April 1st deadline also had me a little worried. All of the MEPs I've seen took at least three or four months to complete. I don't think one month is going to cut it for a lot of people who would want to make a really good track. That deadline would be too soon for me to make the couple of tracks I want to do (I have my own video projects to work on during that time as well).

I've noticed a lot of people show interest, but only a few have actually committed to making tracks. You can't finish the project if enough people don't commit. Either that or the project will end up having hardly any tracks. My suspicion is that the lack of commitment is due to the lack of technical and other, more specific, rules like how Infinity Squared mentioned earlier.

Please don't think we want to take away your idea... we just want the project to be more organized and we want to see more people signing up.
Osakaisthebomb wrote:Like I said before I have chosen to work with sora764. Why? Well for one thing I know the dude. Another is that he lives in the same town as I do now so working on it together would be simple and I have learned aobut encoding and will be working on that with another friend of mine.
Actually, you don't have to be working with someone who's in the same town. Sierra and I are living in different cities and we give each other input on our current video projects ALL the time. We just send our betas and talk over instant messangers. We even made whole videos together across the internet just by giving each other our project files. But, if that's what you want to do.
Osakaisthebomb wrote:if I did that I would have no right to call it my own.
Well technically, it wouldn't be just yours anyway... the video would belong to all of the editors as well.
Osakaisthebomb wrote:there is the chance that the ideas and direction I want to take this might be different than yours.
We would be happy to run all of our rules by you and hear your input on every aspect of the project. We would just want to make sure all of your ideas can actually happen the way you plan them to.


I understand that in the end this is your idea, though. All I can do is make suggestions, then.
- You should definitely take a look at the sticky thread in this forum about running MEPs. Also, read through some of the other MEP threads in this forum to see how other coordinaters handle situations and convince other people to join their projects.
- You should either make a new, official, thread complete with a project title (I had no idea this was a thread for a Christian MEP project until halfway through the first post) and a first page that lists all the specific rules and lists participating members and tracks, or you could update this thread by editing your first post to keep the project up-to-date with lists and such

I'm not sure myself whether I'll make any tracks for this project. I do have several ideas, but since I spend several hours on my videos I don't want to commit to anything until I see there's enough people working on this project to get it off the ground.

Good luck, I really hope this project turns out.
ImageImage

User avatar
Infinity Squared
Mr. Poopy Pants
Joined: Wed Aug 11, 2004 10:07 pm
Status: Shutting Down
Location: Australia
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by Infinity Squared » Thu Feb 23, 2006 12:52 am

Personally, these are the stuff I'd want to know:

- Final video format (ie. what codec is used and what container it would be in, screen resolutions and aspect ratio, frame rate, etc). This'd be so I can make videos that would fit these categories.

- That I'd be able to send to you online (ie. via YouSendIt, RapidShare or any other upload program, or even an ftp site) as I am all the way in Australia and sending via snail mail will be thoroughly annoying.

- Should footages have clean endings and openings, as in you're not cross-fading together different tracks? Or does it not matter and we're free to do whatever we want with these.

- Audio formats, for both what we send to you as well as the final video. Do you want us as well to send the music file separately so you can mix them, or just tag them along with the video itself? (lossless or compressed?)

I'm also sorry to say this but I don't make .wmv videos as I find the quality lacking sometimes (particularly as the platform I am working on creates giant pixels on fast scenes). I'd probably and preferrably be sending you Huffies.

I have faith in you, and this is a Christian MEP after all :P I'll have more faith in you though if you lay my doubts to rest by answering my questions :)
Image

User avatar
Osakaisthebomb
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2005 5:05 pm
Status: 16 kib limit is a crime.
Location: Florence,Alabama
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by Osakaisthebomb » Thu Feb 23, 2006 1:29 am

Infinity Squared wrote:Personally, these are the stuff I'd want to know:

- Final video format (ie. what codec is used and what container it would be in, screen resolutions and aspect ratio, frame rate, etc). This'd be so I can make videos that would fit these categories.

- That I'd be able to send to you online (ie. via YouSendIt, RapidShare or any other upload program, or even an ftp site) as I am all the way in Australia and sending via snail mail will be thoroughly annoying.

- Should footages have clean endings and openings, as in you're not cross-fading together different tracks? Or does it not matter and we're free to do whatever we want with these.

- Audio formats, for both what we send to you as well as the final video. Do you want us as well to send the music file separately so you can mix them, or just tag them along with the video itself? (lossless or compressed?)

I'm also sorry to say this but I don't make .wmv videos as I find the quality lacking sometimes (particularly as the platform I am working on creates giant pixels on fast scenes). I'd probably and preferrably be sending you Huffies.

I have faith in you, and this is a Christian MEP after all :P I'll have more faith in you though if you lay my doubts to rest by answering my questions :)
First question: I'm looking at mpeg as the final file type. I'll have to do alot of testing to see which one will work best. I let you know as soon as possible.
second question:I'll have to look into those sites or programs and see If that will work.
Third question: Do to you hearts content
Fourth question: I'd send a copy of just the song as well. Whatever you feel is better.

My computer has trouble with .avi,.mov,and mpeg-4 files. M-peg would probally be the best bet as to what file type to send me.

Shinodude
emodude
Joined: Sun Dec 12, 2004 1:36 pm
Location: under your bed
Org Profile

Post by Shinodude » Thu Feb 23, 2006 1:37 am

First question: I'm looking at mpeg as the final file type. I'll have to do alot of testing to see which one will work best. I let you know as soon as possible.
second question:I'll have to look into those sites or programs and see If that will work.

My computer has trouble with .avi,.mov,and mpeg-4 files. M-peg would probally be the best bet as to what file type to send me.
I for one would much rather have it be an avi, if you dont have Xvid then your comp will have probs with avi, avi is the best file format, mpeg can get as good quality as avi

Third question: Do to you hearts content
that isnt a good sign....if the mep turns out to have horrible quality it wont become very populare and will be a dissapoint ment to us who spent are time making good quality segments.

Prodigi
is the conductor.
Joined: Sat Sep 06, 2003 2:48 am
Org Profile

Post by Prodigi » Thu Feb 23, 2006 1:37 am

OITB, i agree with many points both SL and SM have brought up. You seemed unsure of yourself in your first post, and this leads people to be worried abuot the overall performance of the MEP, and whether it would actually be finished. You've only started editing recently, and so taking on a MEP is a HUGE responsibility. I'm currently heading up a MEP and it proves to require a large amount of effort. Not only that but the formats you are sugesting aren't the best for a MEP. Encoding a track in .wmv, and then loading them all in movie maker and compressing it again is just insane. With a MEP most segments need to be done in a HUFFYUV compression or an Xvid compression, or else you will suffer major loss in quality. This is even worse when people use fansubs rather than DVDs :(

I'm not trying to be mean or rude, but i just think you might be taking too larger of a responisibility upon yourself. You will have to be checking up on people on a weekly basis, making sure people are working on their segments. Not only that but dropouts are a real bitch to deal with.

I like the concept of a Christian MEP and would be more than happy to submit a segment (most likely to Disturbed's "Prayer"). I just think that perhaps having SL and SM running it would be a slightly better option. SL and SM have huge amounts of experience in editing, and all the technical aspects that would need to be explored, not only that but they're sisters, so working together would be easy for them.

I will keep an eye on this thread and the development of the project, as i am quite interested.

User avatar
Osakaisthebomb
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2005 5:05 pm
Status: 16 kib limit is a crime.
Location: Florence,Alabama
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by Osakaisthebomb » Thu Feb 23, 2006 1:40 am

ANOTHER THREAD COMING SOON.

stop reading this thread and be on the look out for it. You'll know it when ya see it. May take a while but when I get this crap straighten out I'll have more than enough info for you.

Shinodude
emodude
Joined: Sun Dec 12, 2004 1:36 pm
Location: under your bed
Org Profile

Post by Shinodude » Thu Feb 23, 2006 1:42 am

Osakaisthebomb wrote:ANOTHER THREAD COMING SOON.

stop reading this thread and be on the look out for it. You'll know it when ya see it. May take a while but when I get this crap straighten out I'll have more than enough info for you.

I feel you are ignoring what we have to say

User avatar
Osakaisthebomb
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2005 5:05 pm
Status: 16 kib limit is a crime.
Location: Florence,Alabama
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by Osakaisthebomb » Thu Feb 23, 2006 9:53 am

shinodude wrote:
Osakaisthebomb wrote:ANOTHER THREAD COMING SOON.

stop reading this thread and be on the look out for it. You'll know it when ya see it. May take a while but when I get this crap straighten out I'll have more than enough info for you.

I feel you are ignoring what we have to say
actually I'm doing the exact opposite.

Locked

Return to “Multi-Editor Projects”