1 for 1 on my latest

mEISdAVID · Post by **mEISdAVID** » Mon Feb 20, 2006 9:55 pm

kadaj: op is up

SEND MORE VIDS!!!

Hagaren Viper · Post by **Hagaren Viper** » Mon Feb 20, 2006 10:56 pm

mEISdAVID wrote:hagaren: your's is up at last, my net was down all weekend, sorry about that! don't feel bad about the op, it may sound negative, but we all have to start somewhere. keep trying alright?

No, it's no problem. thank you for the honest OP!

mEISdAVID · Post by **mEISdAVID** » Tue Feb 21, 2006 1:07 am

kadaj, I just read your response and I'm not sure you understood the gist of my review. I greatly enjoyed your video and think that it shows enormous potential. despite how my comments may have sounded, I did not grade down any for it being an action video. I love good action videos, they're just hard to find sometimes.

Kadaj · Post by **Kadaj** » Tue Feb 21, 2006 4:27 am

lol, if i made it sound like i thought you disliked it because it was action, then it was my fault indeed.
after reading through your opinion again, i see you have already acknowledged that i didn't use repetitive scenes (bahamut fight XD) so it was indeed my error.
the lip sync mark i suppose was fair call, as most of the lip sync is below scratch apart from that first one. the lip synch in the verses was of course a lot harder to do well, but i still defy anybody to do better with cg footage, and i will stand by that.
Effects i realise are very sparatic, but you have to understand i am an insanely musical person, and a huge system of a down fan. i know in particular chop suey very well, as it was the first song i heard on the path to becoming a metalhead.
Almost all system of a down songs have drastic changes in the composition of their parts - the chorus, verse, bridge, introduction, and ending are all very different, they translate different feelings and thoughts, and the form of the song is ever changing. that was the basis for my editing; it was almost never the same twice. in particular the intro part with the tribal sounding drums. there is no other part of the song with that beat to it, so i purposely made the editing distinguishably different.

lol, i dunno, i typically read to far into things like this, so i probably should be writing this stuff in the comments page of my video (not like people read that stuff anyway XD).

anyway, thanks again for the opinion ^^

mEISdAVID · Post by **mEISdAVID** » Tue Feb 21, 2006 8:14 am

hahaha I read that stuff... I think people read it more often than you'd think. I agree about it being hard to do better with the lip synch, though.

Troyan · Post by **Troyan** » Tue Feb 21, 2006 9:12 am

mEISdAVID

Your vid was oped, I'm waiting for your op:
http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... _id=343324

mEISdAVID · Post by **mEISdAVID** » Tue Feb 21, 2006 10:15 am

no. troyan. that's not an op. I'll op once you put more than half a braincell into it.

text of troyans op follows:

orig: 8 visual: 10 audio: 10 synch: 8 lip: 8 effort: 8 re-view: 8 overall: 8

good: excellent encoding

bad:

general: Real good story

This does not qualify as an opinion and as such will not receive one. if you wish to put some effort into this, please do so and let me know when it's done. I'm not even downloading your video until then.

mEISdAVID · Post by **mEISdAVID** » Tue Feb 21, 2006 10:19 am

Troyan, before you say it, no, strider didn't write much more than you did. he did however indicate that he at least watched the video... I'm seeing no proof that you did.

Strider_Black · Post by **Strider_Black** » Tue Feb 21, 2006 11:01 am

sorry about that man, i can make it more detailed, is there a way for me to edit opinions that i already did.

Troyan · Post by **Troyan** » Tue Feb 21, 2006 11:26 am

mEISdAVID
You don't like my op? Really? You want ask me, why comments so short or empty? Because your vid isn't like me... feeble attempt, sorry.
If I'll correct data I'll write a fair estimation, and it will be considerably below. You need it?