I'm the of the 1st category. I'll give a 10 in a category unless I find a flaw or a detraction; then based on the number and obviousness of detractions, I'll reduce the score accordingly. Not surprisingly, my average given is relatively high (although personally, I blame it more on the fact that most videos I op are wonderful little bits of work).
I haven't really met many people of the 2nd category. I'd imagine their scores would be low.
The 3rd is relatively common, although there's no agreement as to what is average - some go with 5, some go with 7, some go with 8...
And I don't think the org should go out and tell them, 'no, this is NOT your average'. Let them decide what their average is.
As for me, I'll still go with my approach, thank you. High scores? Maybe. But you can't accuse me of not being detailed/justified in my ops, either

(which reminds me that I still have over a dozen of ops I've been owing for a while
