Ok, first "real" anime I saw was Oh My Goddess. Some of the stuff I saw on Japanimation kinda caught my eye, but oh, the mosaic blur was just soooo useful [not]
I started getting away from dbz and the like [saw it on tv, knew it was anime, but got tired of seeing ugly [in my opinion] artwork]. I then fell in love with the "harem" style anime: Tenchi, Nadesico, classic stuff like that. Then I realized that I REALLY hate dumbass heroes who can't make a freakin' decision when the answer is so blatantly obvious at times.
For now, I'd say I've evolved from action buff, to romance junkie. Doesn't even have to be comical. (Boys Be comes to mind, VERY underrated anime) Please Teacher, for obvious reasons. Kei's not an idiot at the end and he doesn't need 20+ girls jumping on him.
These are just one's views, I say for myself. What about you guys/gals? Did your anime tastes change over the years or you still like the same old same old cause it's just "good" for ya?