Anime Music Video Ideas

Whyarealltheusernamestake · Post by **Whyarealltheusernamestake** » Tue Dec 23, 2003 10:41 pm

One question. Why invite opinions about your ideas and then complain when you get them? Some of us object to being bored to death at half 3 in the morning, you know.

Karen · Post by **Karen** » Tue Dec 23, 2003 11:27 pm

One question. Why invite opinions about your ideas and then complain when you get them? Some of us object to being bored to death at half 3 in the morning, you know.

One question, why set up a forum for people to post and share their ideas and suggestions and then tear those ideas apart and flame them once they're posted?. Some of us object to having our ideas and suggestions shredded and flamed you know.

If you and the others find ideas "boring", "mediocre", "overused" and "unoriginal", and think it "selfish" and "a waste of time" for us to post them here, then nobody is forcing you to reply, or even to continue reading them.

Anyway, congratulations. You've made new people like Atsureki and I feel unwelcome here, and uncomfortable about posting and sharing our ideas and suggestions. Rest assured we won't be doing it again.

NineBirds · Post by **NineBirds** » Wed Dec 24, 2003 12:29 am

Being whiny and playing the victim does nothing for your argument.

One question, why set up a forum for people to post and share their ideas and suggestions and then tear those ideas apart and flame them once they're posted?. Some of us object to having our ideas and suggestions shredded and flamed you know.

You posted on a message board that is free to criticism. You recieve criticism. You bitch and moan that people criticized. If you didn't want criticism, YOU SHOULDN'T HAVE POSTED. It's as simple as that.

This is (or at least it attempts to be) an artistic community. Criticism is vital to growth. Please--give me an example where there was any kind of viable artistic community where there was no criticism between members whatsoever.

If you and the others find ideas "boring", "mediocre", "overused" and "unoriginal", and think it "selfish" and "a waste of time" for us to post them here, then nobody is forcing you to reply, or even to continue reading them.

No, nobody is. But given that this is a open-to-criticism community, we may post criticism if we see fit. I repeat: CRITICISM = GROWTH.

Anyway, congratulations. You've made new people like Atsureki and I feel unwelcome here, and uncomfortable about posting and sharing our ideas and suggestions. Rest assured we won't be doing it again.

Good. Your whiny, defensive stance and inability to take any sort of negative reaction to your opinions thoughtfully immediately shows that you would have not been a worthwhile member anyway.

Perhaps one day you will learn that in the real world adults are expected to consider challenges to their world view with some degree of maturity. I hope this day comes soon, because I get the feeling you're going to be whining right up to it.

Krypton-Knight · Post by **Krypton-Knight** » Wed Dec 24, 2003 1:11 am

As much as I don't care for the ideas, since I have not seen Inuyasha I see no reason at all to flame him (and Karen). This is a forum to suggest amvs, people are giving you THEIR ideas that might interest you. If it does not interest you then shut the fuck up and move on. No ones asking for your commentaries on if the ideas are "worthy" of your time. And also what growth do you speak of?

guy 1 : hey your idea sucks, your a noob
guy 1 : to himself(there now he should "grow" and give better FREE ideas)

WTF? how in the hell does it help anyone to feel like crap, and be treated harshly. Theres a differnce between constructive critisim and personal attacks, LEARN IT. Oh and the guy took the time to write paragraphs explaining his themes, and ideas, dont like them? well good for you, keep it to yourself if your not helping the cause.

Krypton-Knight · Post by **Krypton-Knight** » Wed Dec 24, 2003 1:31 am

might aswell get ready....