Post
by KLin » Tue Feb 04, 2003 2:20 am
AD Vision by far. Usually they pack more extras than Pioneer or Bandai. They are not afraid to look up and hire new voice talent for their dubs. Generally they have very good taste in the anime to domesticate. They are going to domesticate lots of previously highly anticipated series by the fan community such as fullmetal.panic!, NOIR, Gensoumaden Saiyuki, and RahXephon. They fit more episodes into each DVD disc than Pioneer or Bandai and at a lower cost per episode.
At Best Buy AD Police TV - To Protect and Serve which is 12 episodes costs 5 dollars less than Vandread Second Stage, vol. 3 which is 3 episodes. ADP TV comes with all character sketches, ADP encyclopedia, all character artwork, clean opening, and clean ending. Vandread comes with foil cards, some character sketches, clean openings, and promo clips. AD Police TV is accurately subtitled, Vandread the Second Stage is not accurately subtitled in certain places.
Just so you know I'm not being biased by the anime title, I like Vandread better as a series more than ADP TV.
And for a non-DVD related positive point of AD Vision is that they set up the Anime Network where there's only anime playing on one channel all day. (Although it's a pay to watch feature) No other distributor has done that yet.
Tokyopop is also steadily improving, right now they're slightly behind Bandai and Pioneer as far as extras and quantity of episodes but they are steadily catching up by including such bonus extras as Tokyopop authentic mangas, friendship charms, and music CD OSTs, and having more faithful subtitles. Keeping the familiar appelations of -sempai, etc.
This is how I'd list the distributors in order from favorite to least favorite:
AD Vision
Pioneer
Bandai
Tokyopop
Anime Works
Central Park Media/U.S. Manga Corps
I own DVDs by all the companies, and I honestly think that order is not too exaggerated.