Sharing The Same Concepts...

[SpPANDA]

ok, lets say i have an idea for a music video.... but then i searched and found there was already a video done, but done reeeeeeally bad. what if i wanted to recreate that concept to my own likings.

can i do that?
is that wrong?

Lets say i watch a video and i think to myself... well... the concept was really good, but the creation was horrible... and knowing if i can use the same concept, i can do better than what was done before.

is that wrong?
can i not do that?

there are a lot of amvs out there...
im sure there are alot of "n00bs" out there that come up with these ideas before we can get our hands on them.

who says we can't use the already made idea?

someone tell me if this is wrong... please?

i think the only time recreation is wrong... is if the video has already won an award. maybe that's me.

even still...

[The Non-Professional]

Its like abortions, some people are for it, some people are not for it. If you think you can make it a Kick Ass video and want to do it. Send me them betas.

[Beowulf]

If someone has made a terrible video with your conecpt, it never happend. Simple as that

[The Non-Professional]

If someone has made a terrible video with your conecpt, it never happend. Simple as that

indeed...

[Ashton]

Gosh.. you guys are right... as a matter of fact, I had this idea, ok, check it out: I was gonna do a whole bunch of really sweet anime like Ah: My Goddess and Excel saga, but lots of different anime, and use this song called Mombolea or something like that by some girl named Elisa, but I found out it's already been done. Good thing it's a piece of crap, I'm gonna go make a better version now.

[Koopiskeva]

I think it's better to come up with something else.

[mexicanjunior]

I think it's better to come up with something else.

Agreed.

[Mr Pilkington]

Just do it! Why do you need other people's permission anyways? No matter what some will like it some won't. The only thing I can say is when reusing an idea, do your damnedest to out perform your predecessor.

[Castor Troy]

ok, lets say i have an idea for a music video.... but then i searched and found there was already a video done, but done reeeeeeally bad. what if i wanted to recreate that concept to my own likings.

can i do that?
is that wrong?

Lets say i watch a video and i think to myself... well... the concept was really good, but the creation was horrible... and knowing if i can use the same concept, i can do better than what was done before.

is that wrong?
can i not do that?

there are a lot of amvs out there...
im sure there are alot of "n00bs" out there that come up with these ideas before we can get our hands on them.

who says we can't use the already made idea?

someone tell me if this is wrong... please?

i think the only time recreation is wrong... is if the video has already won an award. maybe that's me.

even still...

There's nothing wrong since none of us own the copyrights to the music and anime we use. Just do whatever you want.

[The Wired Knight]

Go ahead and make a video even if someone else has done it (save for Linkinball Z). I have a knack for people JUST beating me to my ideas right before I get to work on them. The only reason I would say not to do it is if you are only going to make the video to spite the original creator, that isn't moral and is an insult to the creator. If you want to make a video with the same combination that you happened to have and just want to make it differently, feel free.