That list is very shoneny (That should so be a word), so I'd recommend Soul Eater, based on the stuff you've already watch. Also, random recommendation is AKB0048, because I haven't had a chance to recommend that show to anyone yet
"Never fall for a tennis player. Love means nothing to them"
I've just finished watching White Album 2 and... i cried like a baby. I've never legitimately full on cried from an anime, not even Clannad Afterstory or Anohana. So incredibly real. The character interaction is so damn realistic and the voice actors do an incredible job of conveying emotion.