So after really watching all these.....
Really people? The year of the troll.
1.) Overall I see the concept. but bad lip syncing and poorly lowed footage really took away from the final product. Seems like a beta that needs polishing
2.) The ending text was good. I get the concept but... really, the dub opening. :facepalm:
3.) Can't tell half the time if its an attempt to lip sync or random flaps
4.) I really liked this one! The only modification I would like to see is to keep the bg textures static through edited motions. General motions were really obvious.
5.) Footage issues. Lots of high quality masters out there, an inexcusable mistake.
6.) Your studio is going to ban you soon
7.) I really loved this one, but it's exeptionally hard to categorize. Also not terribly blind (less the file name has been fixed)
8.) The Lipton Award, that's all I am saying about that!
9.) It appeals to my adhd, but I didn't get much of a connection to the song or any story. Also the first Redline video that didn't make me want to get off my ass and watch the show. It looked good and all of the editing was solid, but lacking x-factor.
12.) Needs more cowbell
13.) It was fun to watch, and trolltastic. I wanted some audio editing a bit more complexity.
14.) 15 minutes of the film simply condensed. Very much carried by the "awe" factor and story from the film. Nothing new brought to the table. It was enjoyable, but not what I would consider contendable.
15.) Déjà vu Also, F*CKING AMAZING!!!!
Best parody video of all time.
16.) A good video from a basic edit, but the desaturation was really bad. Some scenes took on too much red hue and others washed green a lot. Looked like the driving effect was an after thought. Honestly, I would have liked the standard version on its own much more.
18.) Overused audio is overused. The video and editing were good, I did like the additions.
19.) The footage way over saturated, bad scripting? The blurring was just too much at times and transitions were far to static.
20.) The masks looked really bad. I mean 2003 snhknives bad. A lot of work went into this and I really hate to say it, but there needs to be a lot of cleaning done here.
21.) The Sponsored by Piggly Wiggly award.
23.) 1/2 cool trailer, 1/2 failure to edit at all.
24.) Saw this at BUY SOME APPLES
, it's neither blind nor particularly great. And that footage
25.) You know who you are and you know my opinions.
26.) I like
28.) Best Character Profile
29.) @3min 10sec in In finally got where this was going.
30.) Toradora! + shaky footage + emo music = win
4 years ago
31.) Direct parody but the lip sync was meh and really not enough action.
32.) It pains me to no end that so much effort went into this, because: DDR arrows? Find Edges? 80's color sat? Really? No plot, no major content? A lot of technical skill but adhd footage all the way through.
33.) AMVCK4: When chroma key attacks
34.) Best Romance
35.) This video made me M@D
36.) Blur-swipe is the new piano keys. I'm just sayin'
37.) This video was technically well done. I think tone for tone it was a good match but the video as whole failed to capture my interest. Everyone else in the room loved it, but to me it just it just lacked some x-factor I can't explain.
38.) Scenes ran too long. Good story and flow though.
39.) Got my derp laugh on. Winner of the Guano Award
40.) More of a hell segment. Funny, but it got old after a few seconds.
41.) d.) Put it in
42.) Scene selection could have been better and the characters were listed in the wrong order. If you know the original youtube video for this and the one previous, good parodies but both suffer from footage that's too static. Though this one did give me the lulz. Best Troll?
43.) I thought MJ retired
44.) Best use of Chloroform
45.) a very long intro to an AMV that never began
46.) Okay SO
much better than the version they had at D*C but the logo suffered in so many ways and made me crazy. Again Lee, you can use the handles on the pen tool to arc lines.
47.) I liked this one a lot! Definitely a candidate for best l/a
48.) 2 videos not always better and one. I get the joke, but didn't laugh
50.) Cool intro, lost it through the best part of the song, cool end.
51.) What do I do with my flag?
52.) Airbud? Troll fail. And where have I seen that art before? <_<
53.) Conceptually great but the video suffered from piss-poor audio editing and lack of defined plot. Could have been awesome, I wanted so badly to love this
55.) F*CKING PHENOMENAL!!!!
Best in show without question or doubt.
56.) This song is so over used we all groaned. But the editing and plot centricity really blew me away! Fantastic job!!
57.) Best Feel Good Video.
59.) 2nd only to #55. Great concept, great content, far superior to any of the above in every way