Actually I think that gaurry was referring to the fact that the whole thing wasn't perfect 4:3 but 4:3 slightly stretched and letterboxed back to 4:3 for some reason, so the whole thing had black bars and had a slightly wrong aspect ratio (noticeable to me, but perhaps not so much for others, I guess)... I just checked the preview, though, but I doubt it's an issue with the preview encode, since the preview doesn't change the AR like that.
As for the vid itself, yeah, nothing so original but I can understand the point of it... I wasn't really able to enjoy it all that much since, while it was obviously edited with other amvs you guys made, it didn't feel as much of a tribute as it was supposed to be - the song just plainly didn't work for this intent.
But I suppose that, as long as you enjoy it, it's fine.
