(The Reason) Why?

Prodigi · Post by **Prodigi** » Sat Jul 14, 2007 12:23 am

Yeaaah, I see what you were doing, but the song for me was just too.... uh. I dunno. I like the concept and the editing was decent, but yeh, the song really irks me.

4/5

aesling · Post by **aesling** » Sat Jul 14, 2007 12:56 pm

I really enjoyed this video. I looked in the topic and saw the song was by Joan Baez and knew I had to grab it. I thought overall that it was a very beautiful and sad video. I had no problems with the music, but then again I grew up on Joan Baez and musicians like her, so maybe I just have acquired that taste where others haven't. Good job overall.

Prodigi · Post by **Prodigi** » Mon Jul 16, 2007 12:40 am

aesling wrote:I really enjoyed this video. I looked in the topic and saw the song was by Joan Baez and knew I had to grab it. I thought overall that it was a very beautiful and sad video. I had no problems with the music, but then again I grew up on Joan Baez and musicians like her, so maybe I just have acquired that taste where others haven't. Good job overall.

My reaction probably would have been the same if I were more used to the vocal style.

Ingow · Post by **Ingow** » Mon Jul 16, 2007 5:54 am

Prodigi wrote:Yeaaah, I see what you were doing, but the song for me was just too.... uh. I dunno. I like the concept and the editing was decent, but yeh, the song really irks me.

4/5

I don't blame you, it's rare enough to see any AMVs using that kind of music around here (not as in there are no female vocalists, but more like that entire Pete Seeger/Bob Dylan/Joan Baez stuff is pretty rare on the org) so I mostly just wanted to share my kind of taste. But thanks anyway ^^

aesling wrote:I really enjoyed this video. I looked in the topic and saw the song was by Joan Baez and knew I had to grab it. I thought overall that it was a very beautiful and sad video. I had no problems with the music, but then again I grew up on Joan Baez and musicians like her, so maybe I just have acquired that taste where others haven't. Good job overall.

Glad to hear that there's at least someone that seems to have known the artist before watching this video ;> I tried to use the most fitting scenes to visualize the kind of atmosphere the song is building up and I was worried that these scenes would end up only working for me and for noone else so thanks for proving me wrong I guess

JaddziaDax · Post by **JaddziaDax** » Wed Jul 18, 2007 11:35 am

that was very neat... sad too

TriGGiT · Post by **TriGGiT** » Thu Jul 19, 2007 7:16 pm

Ingows release... i have been absent.
which is that hip hop like song thats right in the beginning.
I liked it overall, just one thing right in the start you can tell how the black and white feel fits so well, you should have used this more however you used it in the final part only with the "The End" title.

Nice and Simple.

Ingow · Post by **Ingow** » Fri Jul 20, 2007 5:46 am

JaddziaDax wrote:that was very neat... sad too

thanks, it was supposed to be as sad as possible to be honest

CinKrei wrote: Ingows release... i have been absent.
which is that hip hop like song thats right in the beginning.
I liked it overall, just one thing right in the start you can tell how the black and white feel fits so well, you should have used this more however you used it in the final part only with the "The End" title.

Nice and Simple.

That reminds me I forgot to post in your Dead End release thread, I didn't want to bump it from where it was when I noticed I hadn't yet posted in it sorry, but I probably just would've said what I said about the beta (I liked it overall).

The hip hop beginning is a composition between two Jedi Mind Tricks interludes ("Death Falls Silent" and "Triumph & Agony") And yeah I also would've personally added more black&white but I decided against it because I thought that the video might become too dull for the viewers to watch like that. But I'm glad that you like it :>

TriGGiT · Post by **TriGGiT** » Fri Jul 20, 2007 12:46 pm

no prob at all.

that hip hop beat really fits in there, im hoping its a long mix, cant help thinking of an afro samurai video to that song.

Ingow · Post by **Ingow** » Fri Jul 20, 2007 1:18 pm

CinKrei wrote:that hip hop beat really fits in there, im hoping its a long mix, cant help thinking of an afro samurai video to that song.

nah i meant I just merged two interludes together, which means that it's just two really really short tracks. but if you wanna do an afro samurai vid about every jedi mind tricks track should fit (but the main beat from that interlude you're interested in is from the Legacy of Blood album so you might want to check that out first)