Fall_Child42 wrote:Ok, I give.
About video 18.
I enjoyed it.
Have none of you people seen this?
Power - Kanye West
Video 18 is a parody of an actual music video.
I enjoyed it too, & I did watch the Kanye West video afterward... It is also screen saver, though not one I'd want.
Also Kanye West punched one of my friends.
zeiram_00 wrote:Finished my nominations.
(proof i'm doing my part to be fair and unbiased by giving every decent video a shot at winning)
First off, while limiting bias is good, the point here isn't objectivity; AMVs are an art. Secondly, you very clearly demonstrate a preference for action vids/editing style in your scores, so your bias speaks for itself.
l33tmeatwad wrote:zeiram_00 wrote:
I'm a harsh critic

I think "picky" is more accurate, as some of the videos you gave high scores for (#16 is a 5/5? really? It's rather mediocre and there was really nothing special about it...) weren't that great, technical or concept wise. Don't get me wrong, I don't mind criticism of my of my own video, but I expect more out of someone who claims to be a "critic"...
"Harsh" seems accurate to me, so does "Erratic." ...Then again if I had a spread sheet generating random scores it would correlate to mine a lot better than mine correlates to zeiram's, so perhaps I'm just incapable of comprehending such an alien mind.
Finally:
I'm not too psyched about the categories chosen in general. I wish Romance & Sentimental were combined since Sentimental is such a small pool (and Romance isn't a large pool.) I also feel that there is a huge overlap between Best Video, Best Artistic Endeavour, & Best Technical. (Especially between the first two since they are essentially synonymous.)