MEP - ATORI

[Sephirothishere]

"famous"? yeah sure... we better leave it in quotes

As a matter of fact, u are

[Castor Troy]

Not bad, although my main reason for watching was all the lolz comments in this thread.

Lots of decent technical effort, but it just feels like a ripoff of every amv ripoff I've seen for the past few years. When I thought it was over, it just kept going on and on. If it weren't for the hilarious comments that people leave here, I wouldn't bother watching most videos nowadays.

[Panky]

I wouldn't be able to remember such a ripoff from another AMV, probably I missed that one AMV or maybe I have forgotten (not that I remember too much of AMVs I have seen though), anyway I would be able to say that this didn't look as bad as I really thought it would from what I could read. And unless it was a direct rip-off from another AMV, I would say it was pretty decent, if the execution has the same results without taking nothing directly from another AMV, I don't see which would be the problem (did you ever think that the editor maybe hasn't even seen that AMV?).

I agree with the fact that it looks like a compilation of AMV's instead of a MEP, if I were to separate each amv it would have practically the same effect. That is something that affected the most this MEP. The quality of the sound was also bad in some parts.
I liked the Ergo Proxy part the best, it looked like a good combination of effects to suit the video. What I didn't like, though, is that it was hard to find sense in most of the amv's, adding up the fact that there were japanese songs where I could get nothing from the lyrics (and I even find it hard to understand english lyrics ).
I felt that in most clips, due to the fast pace of the song and the editing style, there wasn't any impact as there should be in most AMV's (an important beat in song or something like that).

I kinda liked some of it, even though I have passed some clips, maybe I'll add something more later, but good job

[ShockyVidZ]

ha i gotta agree with the other pros cause im a major cock sucker and a suck up
(goes and smokes weed?)

[godix]

I started off determined to like the video just because Reda didn't. Anything reda doesn't like must have some merit, right? Somewhere around the second minute I found myself thinking 'good god, reda is actually right. That's astounding. He's actually got something right once!'

[xexyzl]

This thread is why I love the org.

Might watch the video someday . . .

[EvaFan]

The lack of admin intervention is the reason asshaulery flourishes here evidently.

Well I enjoyed it's silliness for the most part though I'm doubting you were intending for it to be enjoyed that way. Most of the FX felt unbecoming/corny to the anime, quick example would be 3:04 or 2:07ish... I get what you were goin for at those parts but the execution for the FX there just didn't work IMO. Some of the FX were really well done though, most of them being on the ergo proxy track and the Maria Holic track. Only two tracks I liked actually. The maria holic track was great, simple smooth editing, didn't seem like any of the FX were forced for eyecandy either.

If i could just rate the last 2 tracks it would be 5/5 but as a whole the MEP is 3/5 for me if numbers matter to you.

[Koys]

Kirin the best track

[Gaurry_no_blond]

1st part & fate stay night - not bad.
others - troubles with rhythm, sync, m/v...

[-Reda-]

The lack of admin intervention is the reason asshaulery flourishes here evidently.

Admins won't remove your shit just because you don't like a video; you're actually ALLOWED to do that here believe it or not.