MEP - Nightwish: End of an Era

Nunchuck · Post by **Nunchuck** » Fri Mar 09, 2007 6:59 pm

yeayah

i like it^^ y'all did an wicked job!!!

omegaevolution · Post by **omegaevolution** » Fri Mar 09, 2007 7:15 pm

well I must say that I liked a lot of the tracks, specially track 7, that was pure awesomess

, I just think that the track 1 an the last track were a little weak, but well track 1 was with a "slow" song so you can forgive that

. Anyway nice job to everyone on this MEP, I enjoyed to watch it

4.5/5

EvaFan · Post by **EvaFan** » Sat Mar 10, 2007 1:38 am

Good stuffz

... Nice work jones, i'm glad you decided to make another nightwish mep.

Lockstock · Post by **Lockstock** » Sat Mar 10, 2007 2:19 am

I really liked Ileia, Oropher and Stolen Soul's tracks.

some of the track's were a little eh, with some having interlacing issues which were really obvious :/

FoxJones · Post by **FoxJones** » Sat Mar 10, 2007 2:43 am

My points for the team:

Track 01 - Good. Managed to work with a slow paced song. Made it easy for me to add the starting titles. Kalium sure has habit of killing the characters in his tracks ;)

Track 02 - Average. Expected much more. Scene changes doesn't match the audio in most places.

Track 03 - Average. Same sync problems here. Nice idea, but could have needed some extra effort.

Track 04 - Good+. Kagihime love with excellent sync (though I needed to point some things out during the betas ;)

Track 05 - Good.. though for me the anime choice for Sacrament of Wilderness felt really weird. Not my favourite track, but that's just me.

Track 06 - Good. Had to add the bath scene, eh.. ;) Love the part around "Aphrodite for mortal souls..."

Track 07 - Great-. Even though it has way too much stuff happening on screen for my liking I can't deny that this is awesome work.

Track 08 - Great. Positive surprise. Epic space battle works surprisingly well with Deep Silent Complete. Some scene changes are still off but nevertheless this is one of my favourite tracks.

Track 09 - Great. Can't go wrong with high quality anime like Karas, now can we..

Track 10 - Average+. Worst visual quality of the bunch. I like crossimages in general but here they weren't used very efficiently. Some scenes worked very nicely though which saved a lot.

Track 11 - Good. Do I see some similiarities with track 06 here?-)

Track 12 - Good. Very well synced and the starting transition was nice idea.

Track 13 - Great. My other favourite track. With Planet Hell this track had very intense feeling. I just totally love the part where the screen goes black for a sec and then flickers back.

Track 14 - Good. Didn't quite have the impact I planned, but I got the concept down pretty well. Not really satisfied with it.

Track 15 - Good+. <3 Vewy muchly the part with "..dark chest of wonders, seen through the eyes". Epic! Ending lacks punch.. doesn't emphasize the music.

Credits - Way better than my actual track ;D

Some transitions were bitch to create. Worst ones being 14->15, 9->10 and 6->7.
Transition itself between tracks 1 and 2 isn't very good, but I like how the character in track 1 ends up on her knees and starts on her knees in track 2.

OropherZero · Post by **OropherZero** » Sat Mar 10, 2007 3:04 am

my fave is Bluetrain's KARAS Track 09, just fits in so well, and im glad FoxJone's track didn't give me a heartattack or remind of me little girls cutting up a dead body and storing it in a refrigerator in a garbage dump =O

Autraya · Post by **Autraya** » Sat Mar 10, 2007 3:27 am

you would lol... I watched it and thought I bet that's oropher's track... it was couldn't help yourself

hehehehe

I like Ileia's the most and it was a little disturbing

ShadowNOS · Post by **ShadowNOS** » Sat Mar 10, 2007 5:48 am

Not exactly what I was expecting, but it was good enough. Ileia's part was the best IMO.

kudos all around.

Aneino_Kaijin · Post by **Aneino_Kaijin** » Sat Mar 10, 2007 9:16 am

Ups and downs. Good job everyone, though. I loved the fourth, seventh ninth, 12th and 13th tracks. Overall enjoyable, and I've heard the same from those I've shown. (Though another person had the same comment as you on my anime choice, FoxJones - was unexpected to hear, since it felt natural to me)

Kevmaster · Post by **Kevmaster** » Sat Mar 10, 2007 10:36 am

I love it..I seriously love it..

Well..it started a little boring..I was like, yeah..its average..but then came track 6 ..and then track 7..and I was just like: YAY! Now its getting awesome!

and I was right..Then track 8..then track 9..both were awesome, but I was a little disaapointed of the transition between those tracks =\ It was a little disturbing..

Didnt liked track 12..but then cam track 13 and It was: OMG YAY!

XP

Track 14 was weird, but I liked it XP

and then came track 15 and my Heart was doing a big Jump =] STEEL ANGEL KURUMI YAY! my fave track of the MEP..

All together: Awesome Job, love it =]