Behind The Wall by TheDarkProdigy (NEW ERGO PROXY AMV) =D

[Goketsu]

Mas o menos...More or less, I liked the edition! ... credits are long! 3/5 Bueno!

glad u liked it ^_^

[Goketsu]

Well it just seems like he doesn't like him and thats why he rates all his video like that

Only those who can't take critizm and honesty and who can't search the mistakes in theirselve first would assume something like this.

Ignorant fools, I kind of expected more maturity from you

(orwait I didn't, because I consider you nothing more than any of thoise other 10million imature turds out there on the internet)

Btw Mike, there is an button in this forum, you should probably take use of it to avoide double-posts.

well in your original post you weren't being constructive u just said it was horrible thats why I took offense when you said that and it was also because I thought you were only saying that because its him and ya I'll admit I was being immature at that moment but everyone acts like that at some point and I admit maybe I was wrong about why you said that so I apologize and next time I'll make better use of the edit button

anyways back to the video:
I personally really enjoyed this Milky and I think its your best amv yet and the only complaint i rly had was the credits were too long but other wise it was awesome 4/5
and I would like to say thank you to everyone who watches this whether you like it or hate Im glad you took time to view it

[VRSaskayzx]

Milky is a horrible Editor

i believe your supposed to post your opinion on this thread not insult another editor because you don`t like his way of editing =\

[Kevmaster]

Milky is a horrible Editor

i believe your supposed to post your opinion on this thread not insult another editor because you don`t like his way of editing =\

That is not an insult, it's my Opinion. I haven't ever seen anything decent from him, thus I can safely say, that he is a horrible editor. It is not about his 'editing style', it is that he fails at what he seems to be trying.

I may sound really fucking harsh right now, but this is my Opinion and I'm stating it, regardless of the consequences, I'm just like that. And I honestly don't care wether you think I'm Jackass or not

[RatQuiRit]

Longest credits ever
It's a bit weird that I found it was the best part of the vid, the last 20 or 10 seconds...
This is a good movie but I really wondered why you used some of the effects (like the band masked and colored in blue in front of the anime background, that kinda broke the immersion for me). Lots of blinking that I didn't really like. In the end, it was still an average AMV, I'd give it 3/5 but I expected a lot more after reading Goketsu's opinion...I guess I should have seen it comming agter reading the "good friend of mine" part
Anyway, this was still cool and there's no reason to hate this movie imo (except metal with female singers >_<)

[Kalium]

I liked it, except for the band inclusion in the AMV, but then there will never be a band footage inclusive AMV I will ever like :/ 6.5/10

Yeah... what the fsck was the band doing there? It didn't seem to serve any purpose except to make the video more confusing for me. It's visually jarring at the very least.

Yes, more confusing. I freely admit that I don't get it. Is there something here that the inclusion of the band kept me from seeing? Is it just as random as it seems? I can't tell.

Anyway, the absurdly long credit sequence is more than enough reason for me to delete this. I don't need two minutes of video and another solid minute of credits. That's just ludicrous.

Technically well done, but confusing as hell. 3/5.

[Goketsu]

I liked it, except for the band inclusion in the AMV, but then there will never be a band footage inclusive AMV I will ever like :/ 6.5/10

Yeah... what the fsck was the band doing there? It didn't seem to serve any purpose except to make the video more confusing for me. It's visually jarring at the very least.

Yes, more confusing. I freely admit that I don't get it. Is there something here that the inclusion of the band kept me from seeing? Is it just as random as it seems? I can't tell.

Anyway, the absurdly long credit sequence is more than enough reason for me to delete this. I don't need two minutes of video and another solid minute of credits. That's just ludicrous.

Technically well done, but confusing as hell. 3/5.

not sure whether or not that actually had a point to it (the band being there) but I thought it looked cool the way he did it I'll ask him tomorrow for you since he isn't really active on the forums and also thanks for watching =D

[Scott Green]

Video/Audio Quality |: Hardly any video looks that bad on my LCD TV nowadays (Im serious). I couldn't take the sound comming from my speakers, ugh sounded like someone scratched his fingernails on a blackboard or something. Even with my headphones it was a really bad sound which is just no more acceptable nowadays, it's just very easy to get good quality if you convince yourself on doing so. I'm not asking for perfection (HD and stuff), but just a little more than just 96 kbps, I bet the source mp3 was in this quality.
2nd major bad point... WTF was up with more than 1/3 of the video being credits, I mean whatever effects or sync there were i didn't watch the outro, sry. It's okay to have a long outro in a mep or a long video but a 1 min outro on a 2 min video is just a big NO.

Well it was good edited, the band shadows or whatever were done good. But they are out of place here. I'd more enjoied this video if it was EP only.

Audio Quality killed my enjoiment almost entierly |:
Sorry but it's a watch and delete video for me...
2/5

so much bad points and such few good ones >_>
but it's always easier to point out something bad i guess =\
(insert imo everywhere)

[1arururu]

To me it was uhm............... Yeah.

Just a question.

Are the credits long enough, Really?