Yes it is meaningless. I dont care if you spent a year creating a vid, if it sucks, it sucks. I look at AMV creating sorta like drawing. Some people could do a better drawing than I ever could in 5 minutes, or it'll take me maybe 3 hours to do a really nice painting, and then someone out there will creat one in 30 minutes that is a lot better. I'm getting sick of people mixing effort with quality. Many creators go "Me spent over hundred hours, me put in lots of effort". Then everyone goes "ewww ahhh!!!!". Pfft!! :/bum wrote:Time spent creating an amv is meaningless. Sometimes I spend over a week without touching a project, other times I work for hours a day. This is probably pretty general, as I doubt most amvs would take the time the creator claims if they works at it daily. Planing also saves a load of time and stress.
So far every time I've mentioned this, shit hits the fan and my average review score drops(damn biased bit**es).... Any way I made a 4:17 long video in 4 hours and it got a 4.0 star rating average from 16+ reviewers, and I had that review standing for like 3 weeks, then I brag about me taking only 4 hours on it, and then BAM!!!... in like 2 days I had around 8 more downloads to my video and it droped to 3 average. If your wondering what video it is look in my profile descriptions. Also my first video took me around 8 hours to complete, and it's pretty good ranked star ranking rise, made it about 5 years ago... Also this may be pushing it, especially for me, but my latest video entry took me an hour(another vid I made about 5 years ago). I already knew where everything was going to go in the video since I made the video in my head as I listened to the song, and then I just used my program Premiere on my dads crapn'toss, and it couldn't even save my progress/project, and had a lot of problems exporting. I made it and in my mind it was mind blowing, then I exported it and my system crashed and it got deleted, then I spent an other hour trying to make what I just did, then my comp crashed once again. By this time I was really frustrated and ended up remaking it an aditional 8 times.... and each time took about an hour and the video got worse and worse each time. So actually the time spent on the video is actually about 10 hours... heh, the original name of the video was VEGETA10 because of that, to remind me about how macs suck, and how much effort I put in trying to make the final product of the video turn out like the original one made that got deleted.
On a side note this video is my highest ranked video on a site, and averages out at about a 3.5.... If you want to check it out, GREAT, just don't be biased because you know how long I took on it. Sometimes I download videos without reading the discrip. of it, and the video has a low score, then after watching I think damn that was pretty awesome, and wonder why its score is low... then I look at creator comments and it says something like... "I spent three hours making this". :/ My whole point is people, quite judging a video based on how much time it took to make it. Thats pathetic, just realize some people are better artists than you are.