Phantasmagoriat wrote:Depending on what's in the .mkv, you could simply remux the streams into .mp4
DJ_Izumi wrote:...so transmux it into an MOV or MP4 container and Premiere should happily edit. It can already edit various h.264 formats from a range of cameras, the issue isn't the format but the container.
Pwolf wrote:Just because it can handle h264 out of a camera doesn't necessarily mean it will work just fine with other encodes. I would still suggest converting to lossless rather than just re-muxing into mp4. Never assume that it will work perfectly because there's a lot more to consider than just the codec being used.
DJ_Izumi wrote:I understand that this is old dogma 'TRANSCODE TO LOSSLESS FIRST OR DEMONS WILL EAT PREMIERE' but the industry of video editing has evolved a lot since then.
DJ_Izumi wrote:A 10bit encode doesn't work, but that's hardly a suprise is it?
mirkosp wrote:Hey, perhaps I should start using hours long AVC encodes with a single keyframes as a source, they will load, so it's fine!
But seriously, just because something works doesn't mean it's optimal. Using lossy non intra-only sources to edit is not fast, nor reliable, and I don't see what's the point in making the editing experience a slow and painful one when you could just load blazingly fast utvideo clips and just enjoy the smooth editing afterwords. But hey, not everybody can be a pitcher, so I ain't stopping who likes it the other way.
DJ_Izumi wrote:Honestly, have any of you actually sat down and put this to the test? As you dismiss it, have any of you actually TRIED IT?
Pwolf wrote:DJ_Izumi wrote:Yes. CS5.
mirkosp wrote:Feel free to compare yourself how having 6 1280x720 (no 1080p editing, this is an AMV site, and aside for ghibli movies and the likes 1080p anime are just upscaled from 720p to begin with) avc clips overlayed on each other on 6 tracks, and then try the same deal with 6 1280x720 utvideo clips (whatever predictor you prefer), then come back here saying that it's just as fast. Really, I wanna see that. Oh, and no cheating. Don't make those avc encodes intra-only or with otherwise editing-optimized settings, that defies the purpose (since it's going to be a valid editing choice anyway, but it's not what you get out of the box with fansubs or BDs).
mirkosp wrote:And by the way, industry standard is editing with ProRes, so we're talking 10bit 4:2:2, really.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests