Do you like my idea?

[Sephirothskr]

I've gotten at least 45 seconds of footage into the video.. but.. I'm missing one anime that I cant effing find.

[xstylus]

Sold out at RightStuf.com, eh?

[ibabrak]

I've been doing this shit for 5 years. My videos aren't always extremely well thought out, but this one is different. There's a difference between spending one day on a video and spending 3 months on a video. I want to show the community what I'm made of. Show them that I'm not some "Under class" editor...

The problem is that what you've told us in this thread is that you will basically do action anime that's gonna be random with pretty much no concept at all. You mentioned that you were gonna make it as a battle between good and evil but you never stated how you were gonna execute that. When you are making an amv you should focus on viewers that have never seen the anime you are working with. What do I mean? If you randomly just put in villains from the series and the good guys will fight them it does not really tell the viewer anything. I'm not saying that it can't be a good amv.
You also said that you've been editting for 5 years now but you're description of the amv just doesn't say so. The reason people are flaming you here is because you basically said "Yo guys, I have this amazing idea that involves me editing most of the most overused sources. It will be awesome!! Should I make amv like this?" You already decided to make it since you think it is awesome... why don't you just finish it and be done with it.
good read though

[FreeAMVs]

Well after all this I really just want to see the video. I wish you all the luck!