Kazemon15 wrote:I have to agree with Shin on this one. The real footage from the AMV really took be aback and it felt disconnected to the AMV itself. I honestly couldn't see a real story here either... your editing was good though, it's just the concept needed a little bit more work. ^^
Hagaren Viper wrote:First off WHAT A COOL COVER, wow.
I'm not a fan of using live action music video with AMVs so I've gotta mirror what others have said about that bit, but I'll admit that the live action did fit with the setting of the anime, so it wasn't quite as jarring as I'd usually find it. The ending bothered me as well, partially because the non-ending to the story, and I think the last scene should have been of the series rather than the live action.
I do think it is one of your more successful AMVs though! The song and the footage worked really well together, good choice on using this version of the song. Ignoring my dislike of the live action, pretty much all of the scenes nailed the mood of the song, and the cuts and editing were pretty solid too. And I have to say that the bit where Vash ran in front of the band was pretty neat! I would have liked to see a tad more of that throughout.
EimiJ7 wrote:I really enjoyed watching this! The editing was pretty good, and you were able to achieve a great mood. Yeah, there were some little things other people have mentioned that could have been better, but it didn't take away from my overall enjoyment of your video
Personally I didn't mind the real MV footage being in there. Maybe that's because I was really enjoying the music in this video. I do think it should have ended on Trigun though.
MystykAMV wrote:well to be honest I'm sorry but I don't see the story in this video, it's true the scenes do fit to the scenes from the video clip of the song, but I can't seem to see a story in this video, because all I can see is people fighting in the desert and the red jacket man sinking in the sand >.<
I think the editing was average? nothing special but not bad either, however I really like some of the scenes, when they had more impact. In the first chorus part I wanted to see you edit to the anime though, and not using the clips from the video clip of the song.
I think this scene doesn't really fit either, in the beginning the song has a nice soft melody, and this expression on her face doesn't fit at all, I think you should have used darker and more sad scenes.Spoiler :
Also, sometimes you changed scenes from bright to dark which was not pleasant to see.
I think you should also be more careful with your scene selection, because sometimes you used funny scenes, sometimes sad scenes and sometimes action scenes, so try to improve this part (in my opinion).
Overall nice video, but as I said I couldn't see a storyline, there were many characters and many fighting scenes and I haven't seen the anime either.
Please don't take this very negatively, I don't want to hurt you, this is my honest opinion (and I'm also tired and want to sleep) X_X
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests