Confused...

[superboi]

point in case... I got this quick comment, and I would love to respond to who ever wrote this,

"I didn't think it was good. Okay it was really long and that's a good point, but the quality could have been better and it lacked of sync. I also must complain about the song (free choice, but not my taste) the singer seemed to whiny as for me. You should have left out the sound from the series durinmg the video.... nice for a beginner-vid and congrats for the win, but this is just 2/5 to me"

These are GOOD points first of all, and I would have loved to send a PM to this guy going through each 1, but I can't.

1 - yeah it's long, but so is AMV Hell 3. The biggest problem w/ long AMV's though is the fact that the editor can get frustrated towards the end or after spending so much time w/ it, and just wish to finish it as soon as possible regardless of the quality of the content. I do agree though it is TOO long. I should have edited the part where Julia dies, but I felt it would be better if I showed exactly how it was in the show.

2 - The viewing quality is a bit low, but it kinda had to be so others could download it. The MPG over 300 MB, and is more crisp than Crispy Crunch. As a WMV though it's 12.6 MB, but unfortunately I had to deal w/ the fact that it lost some quality.

3 - I would really like to know where it lacked sync so I can fix it. I've watched this thing so much I know it like the back of my hand, and the only part I can even think u might be talking about is where I show a rose drop cut to a vase of roses cut to spike flipping the trigger for a grenade. It's not as onbeat as I would like it to be, but it's not completely off beat either. It would probably be a Great or a Good in DDR.

4 - song choice... yeah it's emo. Women like it. Men don't. Can't really explain it.

5 - As far as leaving the sound from the anime out, I have to disagree. It kind of acts as a segway (spell check) for when the music turns off, and the anime is shown in it's true form. It also makes it seem as though this is the important part, so u better watch it. It's like a cue for the audiance to "listen up".

And that's it. I want to be able to say that. That so much to ask for?

[Otohiko]

Emo sucks, deal with it.














(and even if I was more than half-serious, what to say? Oh, right - deal with it! I've been told that one of the pieces of music that is very important to me, and which I used for an AMV, sucks - in ops with names on them. And you know, it's important enough not to be affected by some random person's opinion.

Life is like that. I thought you would've learned from emo that, ehm, shit sucks)

[superboi]

lol

[JaddziaDax]

hahahahaha for the valentines day video i did the Brighteyes clip

people asked me what was wrong with the audio cause his voice... i kept having to tell people that it was just his voice lol...

a couple of the people wanted me to do a "full version" of it, but in truth i couldnt really handle listening to him on repeat any more than i already had for the 1 min clip i made....

i commend you for putting up with that for as long as you probably had to just to make your clip...

but word of advice... not many people like brighteyes (female or male) he has a sound thats tough getting used to... because even though he might not be trying to be he sounds pretty whiney... and not manley whiney like nickelback, like kiddie whiney...
~~~~~~~~~~~

and please never again compare "emo" to amv hell cause those are two completely different genres... there is no comparison... its like apples and oranges.. they are both fruit but both have very different flavors, textures and tastes...

a comedy video compared to an emo video are very similar in analogy, they are both amvs but very different textures flavors and tastes.

I'd brush off those comments as in difference in taste...

[Kalium: Negative feedback happens. Complaining about it on the forums won't change that. Thread locked.]