inthesto wrote:Unless that place is Street Fighter, in which case trythil is shitty.

?
BTW,
The usual reason some people say AMS don't feel the same is because their heydey is past and of course the environment AMVs exist in changes. This is what most people end up meaning. It doesn't feel the same because something HAS changed. Usually the person talking about the AMVs finally grew up and quit doing things little kids do (watch anime!) or they just simply no longer relate as much to the environment that is current.
2007-Current - Everyone and their brother is making disposable AMVs. You can get footage that is pretty good quality using bittorrent the day a show airs in Japan and you can make decent quality AMVs before the show even hits DVD. The big thing of the day is streaming sites like youtube and AMVs getting linked on blogs. If one is luckily enough to make a mega hit AMV like Skittles you might even get the JP on Nico Nico Douga to like it ^_^
2002-2006 - I tend to think of this as the dwchang & friends era. # of contests have exploded. amv org has now become the defacto watering hole for AMV fans and creators. Certain large groups of editor friends begin to leave a sizeable footprint on the org. Some mistakenly view this as celebrity status when in fact these people's videos just tend to get a lot of press and views because they have a large number of friends which hang out on the org and actually discuss (something which the previous era hardly ever did). # of known female AMV creators expands greatly. # of editors in general has grown greatly. It is now impossible for someone to dominate the scene.
98-01 - My era =p. Internet scene truly begins and booms with the start of the AMV ML, Dimension video FTP, Mdenny/Hawaii FTP, (and subsequent ftp). Small group of convention submitters compete for epeen.
Pre-98 - Fansubbers made AMVs or their friends used their footage to do so. WTF is the INTERNETS?