It's still a contest on THIS SITE. You have to have videos on THIS SITE to participate. It's no more of an org-centric idea than any other category is implicitly. There's a silent "on a-m-v.org" added to the end of every category, and there's nothing wrong with that. This is a contest for this community. There is no reason for any community to be expected to kowtow to any other community over a site event.MimS wrote:I still hope you create best psychedelic soon or later :rolleyes:
I don't agree with Pwolf, it's a very 'org-centered' idea and it bothers me.... I mean some people are very very helping their own community, are participating in Org but not 'helping' it but you just don't notice them.
I know you'll say that VCA is an Org contest (after all) but imho, it's not. Or, at least, it can be more than that (I even think it should have always been ). Every community I observe sees VCA as a prestigious stuff (despite many non-appreciated results lol) and waits for it every year so, imho again, it must be organized so that every single person of every community has equal chances.
I mean, even before there was this announcement, I know that on AMV-France and AMVNews, there were topics about it...
This.mirkosp wrote:Lifetime achievement award, or something along those lines. Also godix wins it by default.
I think this is a great argument in favor of Pwolf's idea. The current award for Most Helpful can apply to helpfulness in any aspect and area of AMV creation. Having an award specific to this community (theMimS wrote:I still hope you create best psychedelic soon or later :rolleyes:
I don't agree with Pwolf, it's a very 'org-centered' idea and it bothers me.... I mean some people are very very helping their own community, are participating in Org but not 'helping' it but you just don't notice them.
I know you'll say that VCA is an Org contest (after all) but imho, it's not. Or, at least, it can be more than that (I even think it should have always been ). Every community I observe sees VCA as a prestigious stuff (despite many non-appreciated results lol) and waits for it every year so, imho again, it must be organized so that every single person of every community has equal chances.
I mean, even before there was this announcement, I know that on AMV-France and AMVNews, there were topics about it...
OtakuGray wrote:Sometimes anime can branch out to a younger audience and this is one of those times where you wish children would just go die.
Stirspeare wrote:<Stirspeare> Lopez: Vanquish my virginity and flood me with kit. ["Ladies..."]
I agree with this as well (y)CodeZTM wrote:xZAKUROx wrote:xDreww wrote:How about..
"Best tear jerker"
As in which AMV made you cry the most.2x
x3 or at least a "Best Emotional Response".
I'm also fond of the Psychadelic suggestion as well as the one Pwolf mentioned.
I second this idea since I really liked a lot of the IC's I saw this yearChained(E)Studio wrote:Maybe Best Iron Chef.
Since some editors upload their IC's they did over the last year.
This, I think this is a great category. I'm fond of "Best Tearjerker/Emotional response" too.Kosmit wrote:I think Best Story should become a permanent category in the VCAs.
