This was one of the first opinions I wrote, and looking back, I may have been a little bit harsh, because even if the video itself was very flawed, it shows tremendous effort and huge room for growth. With a good mentor I see bright things in the future from Chained(E)Studio.
And of course, my own, and while its not my first video, it was the first video I uploaded to the org, and my first video using honest-to-god Anime instead of Anim-esque American animation. And I'm very proud of the work I did here.
Re: The First Impact Award (Best First Video)
Posted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 11:20 am
by Mol
This
Re: The First Impact Award (Best First Video)
Posted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 12:12 pm
by kamikadze
Re: The First Impact Award (Best First Video)
Posted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 3:37 pm
by Monitor Zombie
Re: The First Impact Award (Best First Video)
Posted: Mon Feb 21, 2011 3:32 am
by Azureblaze
Azureblaze wrote:Here is my vote :
Re: The First Impact Award (Best First Video)
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 5:54 am
by Snowcrash
Cross/fade wrote:
It really surprised me this was a first video.
Yes yes yes and definitely yes for best first video !
Re: The First Impact Award (Best First Video)
Posted: Tue Mar 01, 2011 11:45 pm
by pink haze
Vote Sugar Voodoo, the only vid on the list that's actually a first video
In Eleo's case, you can't compare "La tete dans un nuage" to Dreamer
OK, Dreamer isn't a first video in the first sense but let's say, she and every people knowing her consider Dreamer as her real first vid since it's the one where she put all efforts an editor can put into his AMV whereas the one you linked is just some shitty FF vid by a fangirl (what she still is hmmmm...). You can't understand French : The few comments she received on it are quite harsh! This is also why she didn't upload this one on org, like many people, she just wants to up the vids she considerers interesting.
Well, I think I'm biased but what I say it's the reality : o
Re: The First Impact Award (Best First Video)
Posted: Wed Mar 02, 2011 3:24 am
by Kitsuner
MimS wrote:In Eleo's case, you can't compare "La tete dans un nuage" to Dreamer
OK, Dreamer isn't a first video in the first sense but let's say, she and every people knowing her consider Dreamer as her real first vid since it's the one where she put all efforts an editor can put into his AMV whereas the one you linked is just some shitty FF vid by a fangirl (what she still is hmmmm...). You can't understand French : The few comments she received on it are quite harsh! This is also why she didn't upload this one on org, like many people, she just wants to up the vids she considerers interesting.
Well, I think I'm biased but what I say it's the reality : o
By that logic, I could say that I hadn't put all of my possible effort into editing until my most recent video. That would mean I'll be eligible for Best First Video when next year's VCAs roll around, right?
Re: The First Impact Award (Best First Video)
Posted: Wed Mar 02, 2011 4:05 am
by MimS
The difference is you uploaded your vids, she didn't XD
