Naruto AMV 1:1 opinion exchange

istiv · Post by **istiv** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 2:45 am

OK so here is my new naruto AMV that won the Japan Expo 5rd Impact AMV contest in Paris. I hope that you will like it.

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... hp?v=20215

istiv · Post by **istiv** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 2:57 am

HUm, yes i would like to say too:

as it is number 1 on the top10% list you will see one genius guy that scores only 1... to this amv.

it's sad that there is so poor minded people, that even did not watch at this amv and that are competiting for some top10% contest that exist only in their mind. they don't participate in the a-m-v.org game. this type of guy may be deleted from the a-m-v.org registered guys.

i'm mad because i've worked a lot on this video, and i don't like some people destroy easily like this.

Katsumi_AMVs · Post by **Katsumi_AMVs** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 4:58 am

uh...the vid to ex ops with you hav to be a Naruto AMV?
If the answer is not.... I want to ex ops with you again ^ ^
check the vid that I put the link and I'll review yours OK?

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... hp?v=19301

istiv · Post by **istiv** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 5:40 am

ok i'm going on the moment to check your amv.

dwchang · Post by **dwchang** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 2:52 pm

istiv wrote:HUm, yes i would like to say too:

as it is number 1 on the top10% list you will see one genius guy that scores only 1... to this amv.

it's sad that there is so poor minded people, that even did not watch at this amv and that are competiting for some top10% contest that exist only in their mind. they don't participate in the the Org game. this type of guy may be deleted from the the Org registered guys.

i'm mad because i've worked a lot on this video, and i don't like some people destroy easily like this.

Uhm no offense (please don't take this the wrong way), but I looked at your video since it was rated so high and I don't think it is anywhere near the top 10% let alone #1. I was debating reviewing it since I see a lot of things that could use some advice (it's obviously up to you if you take it), but decided against it since I thought you might just think I was attacking the video. Although...as many on here know, my reviews are quite long and thorough, so I'd like to think that justifies my scoring as opposed to all 1's with 3 words or something.

So yeah, I don't think your video is that good and very much question the opinions of 9/10 of the people who reviewed since I estimate almost all of them gave all 10's (or nearly that). I also question if they are just your friends and being nice since well...friends are like that

. Given there is nothing against that, but don't at all be surprised if you received bad scores because I know I am not the only one who thought the video was over-rated.

With that said, again please don't take this the wrong way, I am just stating my opinion and am glad you are making videos and having fun. Keep it up!

dwchang · Post by **dwchang** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 2:54 pm

istiv wrote:HUm, yes i would like to say too:

as it is number 1 on the top10% list you will see one genius guy that scores only 1... to this amv.

it's sad that there is so poor minded people, that even did not watch at this amv and that are competiting for some top10% contest that exist only in their mind. they don't participate in the the Org game. this type of guy may be deleted from the the Org registered guys.

i'm mad because i've worked a lot on this video, and i don't like some people destroy easily like this.

Forgot to mention, you are correct in that it's sad people take the list so seriously, but at the same time...have you watched some of the other videos on that list? Can you honestly say to yourself and others that your video is superior to theirs? Hell even superior by a large margin?

At the same time, I will 100% agree that you deserve honest reviews from people that watch the entire video, but at the same time, you need to be honest with yourself in how "good" it is with respect to others.

Hope this helps!

Kegger007 · Post by **Kegger007** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 5:25 pm

dwchang wrote:
istiv wrote:HUm, yes i would like to say too:

Forgot to mention, you are correct in that it's sad people take the list so seriously, but at the same time...have you watched some of the other videos on that list? Can you honestly say to yourself and others that your video is superior to theirs? Hell even superior by a large margin?

At the same time, I will 100% agree that you deserve honest reviews from people that watch the entire video, but at the same time, you need to be honest with yourself in how "good" it is with respect to others.

Hope this helps!

I have to agree. dwchang has a valid point. But I also know that istiv has a perfectly good arguement. There is no room for people who do that kind of thing on the org. What you need to do now is contact phade and ask him nicely to see if you might be able to get that review removed. I know it may not make your vid #1 on the list, but it will boost it back up to where it should be.

Just my thoughts, no flames for my opinions please!

Peace.

Kegger007 · Post by **Kegger007** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 5:29 pm

Okay, I made a bit of a mistake there. I remembered the guide wrong. This is the quote straight from the opinion guide in the guides section. Hope it helps.

Seriously, if you think that someone left you an unfairly poor opinion, email the person and ask him/her/it to change it or at least explain themselves better. If they refuse or respond with more hostile remarks, you can theoretically take it to Phade, but it's in everyone's best interest (and especially Phade's) that we all can settle our differences between each other by ourselves in a nice manner.

Hope this clears the problem up better.

Peace.

dwchang · Post by **dwchang** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 5:37 pm

Kegger007 wrote:I have to agree. dwchang has a valid point. But I also know that istiv has a perfectly good arguement. There is no room for people who do that kind of thing on the org. What you need to do now is contact phade and ask him nicely to see if you might be able to get that review removed. I know it may not make your vid #1 on the list, but it will boost it back up to where it should be.

Just my thoughts, no flames for my opinions please!

Peace.

Flames? Bah! No worries.

Yeah don't get me wrong, I'm not saying he deserves an all 1's review (I don't think any video can get that btw). I am just saying that I (keyword is I) don't think it's the #1 video out of wel...tens of thousands of videos listed on the .org.

istiv · Post by **istiv** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 6:30 pm

OK let me explain some things.

i'm agree in the fact that this video is not as good as Euphoria or Tainted Donuts, but what i want to say, is since it was 1st on this list with 8 opinions (others videos have 100+ opinions, for me these ones are good AMVs) , some people don't take time to review it seriously but just crush the score for some reasons i don"t understand... then this people are not making amv... i wonder how you would take it for your video ?

i know and i'm certain that with more opinions i won't be first for a long time because i don't overestimate my video i know it's not one of the bests because i'm working hard try to get that level... and one important thing: I'M NOT INTERESTED IN SOME TOP10% CONTEST... it's true that some (2 or 3) of the people that reviewed it are guys that come to check our AMVs on our channel, so i just asked them to put their opinion, as a lot of people do it on their website... i don't see where i'm mad at doing this.

Then guys, stop think i will take your opinion as an attack, all that i want is constructive opinions. I love doing AMVs then i'm trying to do with my team constructives things, like doing opinions as seriously as we can, with respect for AMV makers. then i can't be calm when i saw this only 1's score opinion...

PS: Paulo> your opinion is done