Naruto AMV 1:1 opinion exchange

Katsumi_AMVs · Post by **Katsumi_AMVs** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 7:20 pm

istiv wrote:PS: Paulo> your opinion is done

MY ops are up too ^ ^

but......strange........I can't find your ops......

Uh... somtimes the ops just vanish when I forgot to put the rank in the vid.....so maybe that happens with your ops too......can you pls check?

OH YEAH I can't forget......GREAT VID MAN ^_^

dwchang · Post by **dwchang** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 7:25 pm

istiv wrote:OK let me explain some things.

i'm agree in the fact that this video is not as good as Euphoria or Tainted Donuts, but what i want to say, is since it was 1st on this list with 8 opinions (others videos have 100+ opinions, for me these ones are good AMVs) , some people don't take time to review it seriously but just crush the score for some reasons i don"t understand... then this people are not making amv... i wonder how you would take it for your video ?

i know and i'm certain that with more opinions i won't be first for a long time because i don't overestimate my video i know it's not one of the bests because i'm working hard try to get that level... and one important thing: I'M NOT INTERESTED IN SOME TOP10% CONTEST... it's true that some (2 or 3) of the people that reviewed it are guys that come to check our AMVs on our channel, so i just asked them to put their opinion, as a lot of people do it on their website... i don't see where i'm mad at doing this.

Then guys, stop think i will take your opinion as an attack, all that i want is constructive opinions. I love doing AMVs then i'm trying to do with my team constructives things, like doing opinions as seriously as we can, with respect for AMV makers. then i can't be calm when i saw this only 1's score opinion...

PS: Paulo> your opinion is done

I take it your not a native speaker of english and thus will forgive you for the grammer

.

With that said, yeah don't get me wrong, I was just saying how I felt and making sure you weren't delusional that you were the greatest AMV creator ever or something. As long as you know that, and more importantly, are having fun the it doesn't matter.

I've said it a bunch of times and I agree that you have every right to be angry at a review where someone didn't even watch it or worse, just did it maliciously (like it looks like). I'm sure I would feel the same. So yeah, you don't deserve that and if you want me to be honest, I think in time, the video will fall numerically. But as you said..that doesn't matter and that's a good thing since a lot of people seem to.

EarthCurrent · Post by **EarthCurrent** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 7:33 pm

It's Grammar, dwchang...two 'A's

Go write him a review since he feels I'm picking on him for not liking the song and docking points for reviewability.

He deserves a few more 'honest' reviews.

istiv · Post by **istiv** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 7:34 pm

mmmh you were true, my opinion didn't appeared, i don't know why because i'm sure of did it. but i fix it and redo it. let me know if you see it, if not, i will do it again

.

and thanks for your opinion, i'm glad that it can bring you something.thx.

Org Profile · Post by **Otohiko** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 7:36 pm

The best artists never reap any massive numerical rewards... but don't worry, I think the most important goal you could have had has been accomplished - having your video seen and plausibly reviewed by a whole lot of folks who took it seriously and bothered to give you good opinions. This is already an impressively popular vid, by what the numbers indicate.

But, isn't it true that Phade plans to remove/automatically ignore all the "1 1 1" reviews? In that case, you don't have to worry.

As for me, I'll DL and watch the vid once I'm free from all this work I got, and op if deemed reasonable.

istiv · Post by **istiv** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 7:49 pm

dwchan> yeah, my native language is creole and french, if you speak my native languages as i speak your's i'm ok you joke me

. And don't worry i'm not pondering to take over the world by my amv

.

Earthcurrent> I stop you now: i never said you were picking on me ! your opinion is done seriously and honestly, so i accept it. but as i can answer, i've tried to defend a little my amv. but when i speak about bad reviewers, i didn't speak about you !!! i spoke about the only 1's score with no comments...

Otohiko> thanks for your sage opinion

it's the voice of the reason.

Katsumi_AMVs · Post by **Katsumi_AMVs** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 8:06 pm

HEY stiv thanks for your ops ^_~

uh.....can I opinate this discussion ?........well opinating anyway....HEY EC your ops MAKES SENSE,cuz you've explain it WHY you gave that scores but the other one.......

and if stiv's vid hav 1 on Capture quality...........
WHAT POINT I CAN GET WITH MY GD AMVS????

Org Profile · Post by **Otohiko** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 8:11 pm

First view, op later (as it has now been deemed quite reasonable

):

This is just right from all respects! At first was puzzled at those funky top-and-bottom bars, but then it hit my why you were using em

insolent.

Some of the funkiest lip-sync - a bit cheezy-looking, but more than adequate!

So I think this one hits the spot. At least as far as being one well-edited, in-all-respects-sufficient AMV. Not over-edited, not showing any signs of being sub-standard quality (despite obviously digisub source), and showing lotsa effort, all while keeping the video short and concise.

Smooth!

Keep it up

dwchang · Post by **dwchang** » Fri Jul 25, 2003 10:21 pm

EarthCurrent wrote:It's Grammar, dwchang...two 'A's

Go write him a review since he feels I'm picking on him for not liking the song and docking points for reviewability.

He deserves a few more 'honest' reviews.

haha! PWNED! Sorry..when I proofread I didn't see that...

As for reviewing, I've thought about it, but wasn't sure since I thought he would think I was picking on him, but now that he knows I'm not..maybe I will.

The major deterent is the fact it takes me like 30 minutes to do a review and my fingers usually hurt afterwards.

istiv · Post by **istiv** » Sat Jul 26, 2003 4:29 am

mmmh go for it, as i said earlier i'm not taking some serious and honest opinion for an attack... i just want opinion back for this AMV -_-.

then stop to make me pass for an evil paranoiac reviewer that see attack everywhere and that will take revenge... i'm not that.

(how it is so complicated

)

PS: thanks Paulo Otohiko for your supports, i think you're understand what i mean by criticizing the only's score. i'm not defending a 1st place, i just defending a free crush of my amv.