
When I leave an opinion, I try to think about it. My opinions are probably not worth as much as an editor who has been around for a while...but I hope that I provide a "fresh" perspective. lol.
I don't necessarily need "useful" opinions though... I've also gotten pretty useless opinions with what looked like well thought out scores as well too. Which brings me back to I really don't care about the numbers, I care more about what is said.BasharOfTheAges wrote:I'd say there's a pretty strong correlation between those numbers and not getting anything useful said though - as if one was a representative indicator of the other.JaddziaDax wrote:I could care less about getting all 1s or all 10s its what is said in the op that really matters to me.
When opinions conflict like that what you gotta do is look at them both separately... go back over the video and try to see what the person saw or what the person didn't see and then decide weather or not your agree with them. It is okay to disagree. What it comes down to is you figuring out what you like in your videos and trying your best to do just that.animedays wrote:The opinions given in the exchange usually nicely tear me a new one, if you know what I mean....and often conflict which only confuses the girl more. One person will say...I thought the sync overall worked well, and another will say there was no sync at all. lol. However...I do use the opinions given to ***hopefully*** improve on my next video.
This reminds of the a time back in 2001 where someone wanted me to give him the most honest and brutal op I can give him. He also promised not to go apeshit on me.Beowulf wrote:Its most brutal when you do an op exchange and someone gives your video a glowing review, says you inspire them to live a righteous life and give to charity, and you have to call their video the piece of shit that it really is. I'm not doing that anymore. If I was some tween on the other end of that I would burst into tears.![]()
Uh.Beowulf wrote:I could write up a big 500 word essay to shred a video but really, who needs that?
...
as if anyone is qualified to judge something as subjective as AMVs
Sukunai, Real Canadian Hero wrote:Note to any Muslims present. Abuse a female in my presence, and you are being sent to a hospital emergency ward with life threatening injuries. And no human law will make me change my mind.
There's a very big difference between telling someone what you didn't like about a video, and telling them what they did wrong. Thats the point I was making.Yingface, PsyD wrote:Uh.Beowulf wrote:I could write up a big 500 word essay to shred a video but really, who needs that?
...
as if anyone is qualified to judge something as subjective as AMVs
Kinda the point I was trying to make earlier. Partly why I made this thread in the first place.Beowulf wrote:There's a very big difference between telling someone what you didn't like about a video, and telling them what they did wrong. Thats the point I was making.Yingface, PsyD wrote:Uh.Beowulf wrote:I could write up a big 500 word essay to shred a video but really, who needs that?
...
as if anyone is qualified to judge something as subjective as AMVs
Castor Troy wrote:I can tell what you all did wrong.
You decided to make amvs.
Truth.