The Dark Iron Chef match (need votes)

[-Reda-]

Video A had far more consistent editing from start to finish, and the source was way more interesting. The lyrical sync at the beginning of Video B was juvenile at best and not at all stimulating. The ending was excellent however, and really demonstrated the full potential of whoever edited it. If I have to look for the better editor between these two, it'd be the editor of Video B since their high point was better than anything the editor of Video A put out.

So, my vote goes towards Video B, despite its troublesome inconsistencies.

Edit: Oh, the vote's over. Go figure.

[NME]

I picked the song to be a bit of a challenge. It looks like you both got a good match in.

Both videos are quite different in theme and style. Looking back at the sources The Dark Knight may fit with the song on a more visual/stylistic level, though Dark City is certainly not lacking in appropriate footage.

Video B takes the trophy home, though. Steve is a force to be reckoned with in IC! Shame about the audio edits.

[ReggieSmalls]

VIdeo B