Abney Park AMV Ideas

[Indoth]

After practicing with Adobe Premiere for the past few months and creating a half dozen or so "mini-amvs" (like 30 seconds of a song turned into an AMV) I'm ready to make my first real high quality AMV. Right now I have three songs from a band called Abney Park which I think have a lot of potential, but I'm not sure which idea to go with.

Idea #1
Song: Herr Drosselmyer's Doll - Abney Park
http://youtube.com/watch?v=1-1HgMQg-mk (Couldn't find a non-live version, sorry)
Anime/Concept: Neon Genesis Evangelion, focusing on Rei and Gendo Ikari.

Idea #2
Song: Virus-Abney Park
(Couldn't find a video)
Anime/Concept: Higurashi no Nauk Koro ni, a basic horror style AMV

Idea #3
Song: Airship Pirates-Abney Park
http://youtube.com/watch?v=-WrPWFn7e2c
Anime/Concept: FMA Movie with the characters reworked as airship pirates.

Idea 3 would be the most difficult to pull off but if I do it right it would probably be the best.
Idea 2 would be the easiest to make, but probably rather bland and generic.
Idea 1 would be moderately difficult to make and probably come out pretty good.

Which one do you think I should take on for my first project?