AMV top 10% - rules

[OhMyBelldandy009]

i see some videos up on the top 10% with 3 opinions and no way to download them... so what happens if i make a video and get 3 of my friends to give me a perfect 10 and never put it up for download? whats the point of having the video posted here if nobody can watch it?

i think the videos that deserve the top 10% are those with a lot of opinions but still rank over 9.5 average. they have sustained the test of many different people and have been given good scores all around.

a video with 3 good opinions ranks way up on the top 10%, and i cant download it to see why its good. maybe a video should have more than 5 or 10 opinions before it gets the honor of a top 10% video...

i can understand why astral shut down his download, but go to the opinion section and trade opinions or something like that... remind everyone to leave an opinion after downloading. give people another shot if you think your video is good. find out if it deserves 2nd place ranking on the 10% list. a-m-v.org is a learning experience. you can learn things by getting constructive criticism and learning tricks, what people like, etc.

honestly i think the rules for the top 10% list should be changed. people should have more than just a few opinions, maybe MAYBE they should have some way to download it. i know some proxy videos arent up for download but still... if theyre posted on the internet whats the point of having no download? to show off your title and your speech about the video? downloads would be a nice thing to have.

Okay, I am a young girl, and have no money to host my own videos. The org is working on being able to host videos, and I'm going to wait for that. You can ask creators to send you a Cd-R with their videos on it if you really need to see it! A video shouldn't be disregarded because it's not up for download. Take "Tainted Donuts" for example. Eric Kobet doesn't have it up for download, but so many people have seen it! It would be a crime for that video not to make the top 10% list! If you want to see a video SO badly, you can probably download it from Kazaa, or get it from the creator, and then you can make lots of opinions! THEN, the videos can be WORTHY of the list!

[Phade]

Hey Paul Kievits,

If a video has 5 or more opinions, the top and bottom 10% scores are dropped. So, if a video has 10 opinions, the middle 8 scores ordered high to low are made into the calculated average. This helps to combat all 10's and all 1's scores.

I thought I had that written down somewhere. Hmmm...

Phade.