He's exercising his right, as a human, to pay as much attention as he wishes to whatever he wishes. That may mean you get ignored. Just as you are not obliged to offer criticism, he is not obliged to pay attention to it.
If you only want to find good videos... Then only download videos with good coments... Pretty simple really. That way the weeding is already done for you.
you've been overshadowed by a moron... oops
OtakuMan22 wrote:HEY!Now I can stand being called a few things, but it really stings when I'm being called stupid! If I was truly a moron, I wouldn't be able to make the long argumentive posts that I am now!
Pwolf wrote:How do you think all the good editors became "good"? we opened a magic box and the fairy dust turned us into these editing machines?
OtakuMan22 wrote:or even better, stop downloading the "bad" ones! no one will care either way.
You know, I've been having problems descerning the good from the bad ones because some vids, for some reason, don't have any opinions attached to them when 1, 2, or even 9 people give opinions. I can see WHO left opinions, but not read what they said. This then makes it very difficult for me to know if it's good or bad, and really makes searching for good vids difficult if the opinion isn't available. I know the opinions aren't given in the search results, but there seem to be more and more individual vid pages that don't have the opinions listed.
Scintilla wrote:OtakuMan22 wrote:or even better, stop downloading the "bad" ones! no one will care either way.
You know, I've been having problems descerning the good from the bad ones because some vids, for some reason, don't have any opinions attached to them when 1, 2, or even 9 people give opinions. I can see WHO left opinions, but not read what they said. This then makes it very difficult for me to know if it's good or bad, and really makes searching for good vids difficult if the opinion isn't available. I know the opinions aren't given in the search results, but there seem to be more and more individual vid pages that don't have the opinions listed.
Well, if you donate, you can see the star scale stats of videos other than your own. Or so I have been told.
And stars are more often given than opinions (since they're basically mandatory for local downloads), so they should be more helpful.

Kalium wrote:OtakuMan22 wrote:...but what if it's not just you? What if ALL the fanboys and fangirls did this! Then not only would the space in the org fill up, but there would also be a wide number of more bad videos to sift through.
You don't seem to understand: that, ultimately, is the Org's goal (well, part of the goal). To have every AMV ever made availible here.
I understand that if you like the vid, and someone says it stinks, that's subjective yes. But the thing that bugs me from Trythil is that it's not "vic bashing" that he's ignoring. He comes off as soundling like he's ignoring EVERYTHING OTHER PEOPLES SAY, GOOD OR BAD! For example, if you made a video that you thought was good, but someone thought it could use some improvement (as in they see your idea or point, but have some suggestions for key scenes or parts) and then posted some constructive criticism, would you ignore it just because it's criticism alone?
Donators have many site bonuses:
More Super Search Features:
* Star Information in Search Results List
* Expanded Anime Search Options
* Filter By
--- Star Rating
--- Percentile
--- File Size
--- Spoilers
--- Download Status
++++ Already Downloaded
++++ Not Yet Downloaded
* Sort By
--- Stars
--- Opinion Count
More Video Information:
* Detailed Star Information for the Video
* "Already Downloaded" Indication
And More:
* "Already Downloaded" Indication on the Top Star Scale Lists
* Daily Upload Stats Graph on Member Main Page
* More Results in "New Videos" List on the Member Main Page
* Your Star Rating Indications on VCA Ballot Pages
* Donation Status Display Option
--- Member Profile
--- Forum Post Member Info
first off, no one here gets paid to make amvs or help anyone making them. so why should "good" editors (or anyone for that matter) help noobs?
most of the good creators i know don't have the time to help anyone. some advice? well, probably the number one thing is read the guides... everyone says it. a simple search or short read of the guides will give any newb all the information they need.
the best way to get "advice" and "tips" is to get someone to look at one of their videos... if their good at giving feedback, they'll tell you want you can work on. but, you can't do that without making a video first. but you people are saying they shouldn't show anyone their dbz crap... if they don't want help and think they are good... so what, if you think they suck, then so be it! let them live in their little fake world.
Pwolf wrote:also, what "good" editors here say "you suck and you should quit"? i see a lot of newbs say it to other newbs... any experienced editor knows how it was when they were starting out and i don't think any of them would tell any newb to just give up without reason... unless your sammy, but he's not that good anyway... :X ohh, look what i said...
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests