Good AMVs Bad AMVs, Is there such a thing?

[requiett]

Fans of Naruto will all get theirs in the end.

[DTJB]

WELL, WHAT WOULD YOU RATHER WATCH, HOMES? SOMETHING BY KEVIN CALDWELL, OR THE LATEST TRIBUTE TO NARUTO: COMPLETE WITH WHINY ASS-NOISE MUSIC AND .WMV FORMAT?

How about, if it were at all possible, a Naruto tribute done by Kevin Caldwell?

[devilmaykickass]

WELL, WHAT WOULD YOU RATHER WATCH, HOMES? SOMETHING BY KEVIN CALDWELL, OR THE LATEST TRIBUTE TO NARUTO: COMPLETE WITH WHINY ASS-NOISE MUSIC AND .WMV FORMAT?

How about, if it were at all possible, a Naruto tribute done by Kevin Caldwell?

Then that would automatically make it the most awesomey awesomest awesome thing ever, like that Evangelion video of his, would it not?

[bum]

I thought you thought engel was overrated

[Scintilla]

I thought you thought engel was overrated

Hence the heavy sarcasm in his post.

[Evleyne]

i'm so lost, i can't see any music vidoes! can someone help me? because everytime i click on the LOCAL button to download or view a video it does nothing, i'm i doing something wrong?

[AMVfreak]

i'm so lost, i can't see any music vidoes! can someone help me? because everytime i click on the LOCAL button to download or view a video it does nothing, i'm i doing something wrong?

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/guides/ ... r/down.htm
http://www.animemusicvideos.org/guides/playback

[SarahtheBoring]

Am I the only editor on this site who makes vids for the same reason most people watch them? To see their favorite characters with songs that they like?

No. Unfortunately, I'm the other one.

Am I the only editor on this site who reads the original post in this thread as "wah wah other videos get good scores and mine doesn't, I am entitled to high scores blah blah emo"?

'Cause aishiteru, just FYI, you can't compare things that simply. Yes, videos you hate will get better scores than yours. Yes, videos you slaved over for hours might get bad scores. That's because not everyone thinks the same way you do. Welcome to the org. Hell, welcome to earth. Enjoy your stay.

Right now, some video you think sucks is getting high scores, and there's nothing you can do about it. If you see this as a dire, life-changing injustice that eats you up inside like a deadly poison, consider Paxil and/or a new hobby. That's just the way things are, and in the larger scheme of things I don't think it matters that much.

...but then again, I make videos because I like the series I watch (going back to the first point), so what do I know.

[rubyeye]

You know, I just got back from our little A-kon AMV Judging panel and I can seriously tell you with clear absolution - there really is such a thing as a Good and Bad AMV.


~ and God! There are a lot of really bad (& good) videos.

[bloodyhawk]

thats true like, i dont like the AMV's where the anime characters are saying the lyrics to the song, but to most people thats good.. when i think of a bad amv i think of a vid its the qualty that makes it bad. hopefully that makes sense

[Shun]

"Souls of Rage and Sorrow".

My gahd i need to redownload that video :O

[ashiteruSweetSurrender]

Am I the only editor on this site who makes vids for the same reason most people watch them? To see their favorite characters with songs that they like?

No. Unfortunately, I'm the other one.

Am I the only editor on this site who reads the original post in this thread as "wah wah other videos get good scores and mine doesn't, I am entitled to high scores blah blah emo"?

'Cause aishiteru, just FYI, you can't compare things that simply. Yes, videos you hate will get better scores than yours. Yes, videos you slaved over for hours might get bad scores. That's because not everyone thinks the same way you do. Welcome to the org. Hell, welcome to earth. Enjoy your stay.

Right now, some video you think sucks is getting high scores, and there's nothing you can do about it. If you see this as a dire, life-changing injustice that eats you up inside like a deadly poison, consider Paxil and/or a new hobby. That's just the way things are, and in the larger scheme of things I don't think it matters that much.

...but then again, I make videos because I like the series I watch (going back to the first point), so what do I know.

Geesh!! lol i'm sorry!! I didn't mean to offend you! I honestly didn't mean it that seriously when I posted it... I was just venting... I think it's funny how long my one post went for! Please don't hate me... yes, I was being emo but... we all have our days right?

--{xoxo}sakari.

[donone]

1) fuck opinion, of course there are good and bad amvs. if there isnt then picasso and mozart are just two bums who arnt even good at anything

2) i make amvs to see how good i can make them

[glaska]

There shoud not even be such a question like is there bad and good AMV's. Ofcourse there is so many bad AMV's. People even not trying to fill some special FX. Some just take the beginnig of the anime and atach music and that's all. i really hate stuff like that

[[Mike of the Desert]]

1) I make AMV's based on what I want, not what is "cool" or expected
2) If I'm happy with the video, and no one else likes it, then it's their problem.

Despite the level of competition I've managed to get myself into in the past two years, I fully agree with both of these.

Same for me so X3.

And I sincerely don't know what more to say without create a hell xD