Ehi! Firstly thanks for the opinion, I appreciated it!
I would like reply about the “effort”: I worked hard on this video( I edited this in 2 months, all day but this is not very important) and used “random clips”(as you said) because i didn’t want to create a story, a context or a relationship between the characters. As I wrote in the description, this song is my favourite, i edited it in a “emotional” way. While I was editing i searched to convey what i feel when i listen to this song, so I aimed to the emotions, I wasn’t worried about it seemed “random”. Indeed when i wanted to make a sad clip i chose to put it in a good way, I repeat my target wasn’t not to create a story. As I hope you know, try to edit with a Oasis’s song is very difficult(particularly with this song), because their lyrics, or their musical rhythm are special, and not common. To solve this problem I aimed to transmit the power of the song, and sometimes i tried to follow the lyrics(as you said “Cannonball” ecc…ecc..). About the length of “Champagne Supernova” is 7:27 minutes not 9 minutes as you said, but it’s not important
I don’t understand when you said “That's normally a death knell for AMV's, but Champagne Supernova also happens to be a major radio hit that everyone knows, so maybe it'll slide on that.“(e.g) I’ve never seen a video made with this song
Defeniteily I really enjoyed your critics(they were very helpful) I hope there are other times to talk with you, I decided to reply about your opinion only because I wanted to let you know which is the true concept of this video. I apologize you if I was impolite, thanks again!