Mkid wrote:oh and the winners should become judges BTW.
CodeZTM wrote:Top 3 : Offer of being a future Project OrgEditor Judge or part of 2013 Theme Coordination Team
I just think none of the winners wanted to become judges.
Mkid wrote:oh and the winners should become judges BTW.
CodeZTM wrote:Top 3 : Offer of being a future Project OrgEditor Judge or part of 2013 Theme Coordination Team
Ileia wrote:Rendakor wrote:The blind judging works very well so that the judges can be brutally honest (after all, that's what the Org's known for) in their evaluation. We didn't have the drama that happened in the Quickeningbut even so, I'd hate to have the judges pull their punches because their names were being attached to the comments.
Yue only posted the judge's comments once and those comments were blind (until after said "drama" when the judge in question outed himself), so whether or not you know who said what, there can still be drama.
BasharOfTheAges wrote:Ileia wrote:Rendakor wrote:The blind judging works very well so that the judges can be brutally honest (after all, that's what the Org's known for) in their evaluation. We didn't have the drama that happened in the Quickeningbut even so, I'd hate to have the judges pull their punches because their names were being attached to the comments.
Yue only posted the judge's comments once and those comments were blind (until after said "drama" when the judge in question outed himself), so whether or not you know who said what, there can still be drama.
Yea, but in PoE the judges all stuck to commenting on the videos even if the comments were harsh. Before they were deleted, the offending comments from the Quickening that got people going were making remarks about the editors. It's one thing to critique and make a harsh value judgment about a video, but to frame your comments as critiques on the person that made them instead of the thing they made was unnecessary. That's actually the core difference between critique and flaming.
Return to Project OrgEditor Season 2
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests