Project OrgEditor Semifinals : A Good Good Year

[Radical_Yue]

I'll have to go with a no on that one.

Seriously?

You allowed covers of 80s songs, despite the HUGE ranges of 80s music. You allowed covers from the 80s of earlier songs. You allowed antiheroes in you villain round.

So many videos won multiple awards in the JCAs/VCAs that this category is immeasurably narrower than any of the other rounds, and you want to narrow it further? :\ As a member of the non-participating audience I'd rather not see the same vids covered multiple times, and opening the category up a bit would help that.

Stop crying, there are enough Shin videos to go around.



I kid.

[Nya-chan Production]

I'll have to go with a no on that one.

Seriously?

You allowed covers of 80s songs, despite the HUGE ranges of 80s music. You allowed covers from the 80s of earlier songs. You allowed antiheroes in you villain round.

So many videos won multiple awards in the JCAs/VCAs that this category is immeasurably narrower than any of the other rounds, and you want to narrow it further? :\ As a member of the non-participating audience I'd rather not see the same vids covered multiple times, and opening the category up a bit would help that.

It's one round later, of course the picks are getting narrower and narrower

[Radical_Yue]

It's be kinda cool if each editor was assigned a year of VCAs that they had to pick from. But then again, too late to do any major changes since I'm sure everyone already has their videos picked out for the most part

[Warlike Swans]

I'll have to go with a no on that one.

Seriously?

[Ect.]

It's one round later, of course the picks are getting narrower and narrower

No, I maintain that it's ridiculous. The first 3 rounds were disappointing broad and this one is a tightrope. If the point was to get narrower and narrower it should have become narrower in much more regular of increments.

It's be kinda cool if each editor was assigned a year of VCAs that they had to pick from. But then again, too late to do any major changes since I'm sure everyone already has their videos picked out for the most part

This would have been cool.

[CodeZTM]

I'll keep those ideas in mind for future contests.

______________

So how's everyone doing? Having fun? Wanting to murder me and the theme committee violently?

[TritioAFB]

I don't want to murder you, I like this theme

Wait. I'm not participating

[Nya-chan Production]

I don't want to murder you, I like this theme

Wait. I'm not participating

This. This oh so much~

[Ror0noaZoRo]

so quiet.. you can feel the tension of this round

[Eake4]

so quiet.. you can feel the tension of this round

The silent tension. I like the idea but really the case is probably going to be Code recieveing every submition last minute

[siny]

I need a miracle to finish mine lol