Rider4Z wrote:Radical_Yue wrote:So far, I've yet to see any flaming going on. Only opinions that were interrupted as insults for some odd reason. But relying on the good as a crutch to keep you going, while not acknowledging the bad and attempting to fix what is wrong doesn't really get you anywhere.
There is a pretty big gap between direct criticism and flaming >.>
Of course, those who don't know how to take criticism interrupt almost everything negative as an attack/flame.
i didn't say people were flaming. i was talking about MY mind and MY thoughts. but since you inverted it just replace "forum flame" with an "overall negative view on the contest" which i choose not to harbor. if i feel something needs changing then i'll voice it in my own way, which probably doesn't mean using a forum debate.
and if someone doesn't respond to criticism enthusiastically it doesn't necessarily mean that they can't take it, it's most likely because of the way the criticism was delivered. if they don't feel respected then don't expect them to give respect in return.

xstylus wrote: I wish there was more room in the categories for some of the others to have gotten in, but then that'd make for one excessively long competition.
xstylus wrote:For the most part, Michael has received far more complements than complaints, so I'd say he can declare mission accomplished for this year.
Castor Troy wrote:drama
xstylus wrote:
It's not drama until wrists are slashed.

Rider4Z wrote:those ballads were totally awesome

Perfect-Blue wrote:Drama Category Winner:
Video: Dare to Love Again
Category: Drama
Anime: Clannad, Clannad After Story
Song: Carnival of Rust
Artist: Poets of the fall
Creator: Perfect-Blue
Link: http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... p?v=181555

Perfect-Blue wrote:Drama Category Winner:
Video: Dare to Love Again
Category: Drama
Anime: Clannad, Clannad After Story
Song: Carnival of Rust
Artist: Poets of the fall
Creator: Perfect-Blue
Link: http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... p?v=181555
The Wired Knight wrote:Rider4Z wrote:those ballads were totally awesome
There was a ballad? I didn't realize Michael sang.
Perfect-Blue wrote:Drama Category Winner:
Video: Dare to Love Again
Radical_Yue wrote:xstylus wrote:
As for community judges, I don't really see how that would be a problem. I've actually been talking with Ben about it and I feel that bringing him, along with Pwolf and Castor Troy would be excellent judges. They've got an eye for quality and diverse tastes among the three of them to offer an excellent opinion on the videos for the contest during the judging process. I don't really see the need to DQ them from the contest or make them ineligible to judge based on whether or not they entered. As long as they vote unbiasedly then there shouldn't be a problem. Kisanzi and I do the same thing for NDK and I've entered the past two years, we have friends entering and he's even trying for a submission this year. Hell, most of the time I give my videos a ranking of 4/10 because, even though their mine, I feel that's what they honestly deserve. Besides, I don't see those 3 guys stamping their feet and whooping like idiots every time their own video plays so they would probably be the best choices ;p
Ben has already said he'd be down for it, same with Scott and I don't Ryan would have a problem
Or if anything, just don't let them judge their own videos. As long as the final judging is done off a general average based system and not adding up scores, it would be fine.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest