Pwolf wrote:Castor Troy wrote:Who will be brave enough to challenge me on the battlefield?!![]()
*cough*
But you can't mistake my not wanting to go to AX as not being brave enough to face you ;P
How can I defeat the king?!
Pwolf wrote:Castor Troy wrote:Who will be brave enough to challenge me on the battlefield?!![]()
*cough*
But you can't mistake my not wanting to go to AX as not being brave enough to face you ;P
Pwolf wrote:Castor Troy wrote:Who will be brave enough to challenge me on the battlefield?!![]()
*cough*
But you can't mistake my not wanting to go to AX as not being brave enough to face you ;P

Rider4Z wrote:mr.stylus, any idea when Chef is going to take place?
4) All edits must be entered into the primary edit timeline and ready for final render by the time the three hours elapse. Final rendering shall begin immediately at that time. However, any advanced work (such as After Effects) must be rendered and integrated into the primary timeline before the three hours elapse.
Pwolf wrote:on a side note, the event's #1 priority, while still a competition, should be to entertain the audience. if you DQ an editor because they didn't render stuff out of AE before the time limit, you're only hurting the people who sat there for 3 hours expecting to see something cool but ended up seeing someone get DQd because of something minor.
I doubt anyone is going to be making complex enough comps that will take a long time to render anyway. I assume the AMV Editor block is 4 hours long to allow enough time?
I actually wonder what Vic would say about this. I don't think it's ever been an issue for Iron Editor.
Rider4Z wrote:well instead of DQing, how about working the judging on a point system. and you get knocked points for not having everything together in time for the final render?
Pwolf wrote:Rider4Z wrote:well instead of DQing, how about working the judging on a point system. and you get knocked points for not having everything together in time for the final render?More or less, the video is incomplete at that point so absolutely.
I take that back, you're not judging the editors based on how long it takes to render their videos, youre judging them based on what they did editing wise within the given time frame. rendering isn't a test of skill or talent, it's technical.
Rider4Z wrote:Pwolf wrote:Rider4Z wrote:well instead of DQing, how about working the judging on a point system. and you get knocked points for not having everything together in time for the final render?More or less, the video is incomplete at that point so absolutely.
I take that back, you're not judging the editors based on how long it takes to render their videos, youre judging them based on what they did editing wise within the given time frame. rendering isn't a test of skill or talent, it's technical.
... was that a yes or no?
last year there wasn't a scoring system, the judges decided together unanimously who the victor was.
liiiiiiiight buuuuullllllb
so how about this year the judges have an actual scoring system just like in (the real) Iron Chef? judges can give comments as they see fit after the initial viewing, then pass in their talleys, and the MC (brad) can announce the winner.
xstylus wrote:There will be judgement!
A judging panel of select veteran AMV creators and past contestants shall score the videos using the following 50-point criteria:
Use of secret ingredient: 15 points
Use of theme: 15 points
Technical merit: 10 points
Artistic merit: 10 points
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest