ExSphere wrote:Sources with fluid animation make for an easier source to edit with. But as long as your judges can look through that and see who used there source to the best of it's potential, then there should be no issue.

Ileia wrote:If you're going to have judges who value videos based solely on source, you could forgo the whole editing part and just show them which DVDs you own.
Vivaldi wrote:It seems to me the editor should take that into consideration when choosing his sources. I mean sure, the song selection will have a profound impact on how well the source can be used, but it's just common sense to use a source that doesn't need a very specific set of circumstances to work.
JaddziaDax wrote:You also gotta take into consideration that the style of a Samurai Champloo video is going to be way different than Gravitation because Champloo is an action/drama series while Gravitation is a comedy/romance series, so of course the videos will turn out differently... but just because Gravitation doesn't have a lot of action in it that doesn't make it a worse source to edit with, that just means you are less likely to make an action video with it.
Vivaldi wrote:It seems to me the editor should take that into consideration when choosing his sources. I mean sure, the song selection will have a profound impact on how well the source can be used, but it's just common sense to use a source that doesn't need a very specific set of circumstances to work.
JaddziaDax wrote:One has older animation one has newer animation. I guess I don't tier them in that way because I take the context of when they were made as well.
Not to mention my statement about familiarity still stands. I'm sure that someone more familiar with Kenshin will do better with it if they are not very familiar with Champloo.
gotegenks wrote:The old-school anime lover can ic in some of the lower tiers where his lowly kenshin and YuYu stand a chance.
Pwolf wrote:gotegenks wrote:The old-school anime lover can ic in some of the lower tiers where his lowly kenshin and YuYu stand a chance.
wait? kenshin isn't as good as eva rebuild or ac? fucking kids -_-
Nya-chan Production wrote:Ileia wrote:If you're going to have judges who value videos based solely on source, you could forgo the whole editing part and just show them which DVDs you own.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests