Radical_Yue wrote:Probably because I make the images out of order and a lot of criticism is very similar so I have to word it differently.
Unless you wanted 6/8 videos that just say "solid sync" and nothing more.

Well, like I said in another thread, all the videos this round actually had very similar strengths and weaknesses. They all did a really good job with timing and sync (though I personally thought Ileia and Riccardo's were best in this aspect), with overall atmosphere and action (here I thought Ileia and Mally did best), lyric sync and story layout (here I thought Lopez and Mally did best though)? They also shared the same weaknesses, including somewhat weak endings and some amount of random/repetitive action. I think for me as for a lot of judges, the call came down to deciding who did the most things decisively better than other videos, because objectively speaking, everybody did a really good job this round. It's not like you can point to one of the videos this round and say "you screwed up, you're out!"?
I'm sure, by the way, that the final standings were really close. The results of this round aren't the same as my votes. I'm sure different judges thought differently.